All Forums > Gridiron Dynasty Football > College Football > Playoffs, a season early
10/14/2013 2:19 PM
Alabama vs. OSU
Oregon vs. Clemson

Of course, Clemson could be out with a loss to FSU this weekend.
10/14/2013 3:41 PM
I think UCLA and OSU are close for the 4th spot. A win over Stanford this weekend would put UCLA in my #4 spot, with the winner of FSU/Clemson being in the #3.
10/14/2013 4:24 PM

OSU will have a tough time hanging onto the 4th spot all season.

10/14/2013 4:53 PM
I agree. When your non-conference schedule is Buffalo, Cal, San Diego St, and Florida A&M you're getting what you deserve.
10/15/2013 4:30 PM
Posted by MikeT23 on 10/14/2013 4:24:00 PM (view original):

OSU will have a tough time hanging onto the 4th spot all season.

Ohio State (if unbeaten) will easily finish in the top 4 because there won't be more than 3 other unbeatens ahead of them (Louisville/Houston, Fresno St, or Northern Illinois would finish behind them and I suspect Texas Tech and quite possibly Baylor would as well) and they will finish ahead of a 1 loss team.  Now sure they need some help to finish in the top 2 with their schedule, but top 4 wouldn't be a problem.
10/17/2013 8:43 AM
Personally, I think a 1-loss SEC team could pass them. 
10/17/2013 9:14 AM
In a different year, I'd tend to agree, but I think this year it's going to be really tough for the SEC to end up with a 1 loss team that would be attractive enough to push over an undefeated OSU.  Some scenarios I can see, several of which involve Bama losing which would probably mean that the SEC doesn't have an undefeated team.

But even if they get passed by a 1 loss SEC team, you'd still have to have 3 other undefeated teams from major conferences to push them to #5.  That's pretty rare.
10/17/2013 9:40 AM
Looking at the standings, LSU/TAMU/SC could finish with one loss(but that's gonna push Bama to a loss also unless it's TAMU).   So I guess it has to be BAMA, Oregon, Clemson/FSU as undefeated with TAMU's only loss to BAMA.    One loss TAMU over OSU?    I could see that.   
10/17/2013 9:42 AM
SC could finish with one loss, by winning the East and beating Bama in the conference championship, but I don't see both BAMA/SC with 1 loss over undefeated OSU.   Although, quite frankly, it would be just as that would leave three 1-loss SEC teams with their only losses being to another SEC team.
10/17/2013 9:52 AM
Alabama going undefeated and TAMU not losing another game was the most likely scenario I saw, and since TAMU has to go to LSU, I don't see that as particularly likely.  And I also don't see TAMU jumping OSU in the polls in that scenario either.   Now, if we were heading for a 4-team playoff and it was like it is now where the BCS standings were the final say on who gets in, I could see it being a source of discussion/debate among the voters given OSU's schedule, but this year, I don't think OSU gets jumped by a 1 loss team as long as they are undefeated.  Maybe if they had a really ugly win at the wrong time.
10/17/2013 9:58 AM

I'm looking beyond records(which I think is what the committee is charged with).    SC certainly hasn't looked very good in several of their wins but TAMU has.    But that means they have to beat LSU on the road.   With a convincing win, I could put them over an undefeated OSU without a problem.

10/17/2013 10:16 AM
Sure, I could see an argument for it.  I'm really just saying that I think a lot would have to break against OSU for a scenario to arise where they wouldn't be in the top 4 at season's end if they don't lose.  As easy as it is to look at things right now and think there could be 3 other unbeatens, history suggests one or two of those teams will take an unexpected loss.   And, one of those unexpected losses could be by OSU, which would obviously make this all moot.
10/17/2013 10:33 AM
I guess my point is that I think the objective is to put the 4 best teams in the playoffs.   If OSU can't win their games convincingly(and they didn't against WI or Northwestern), I'm not sure I could make an argument for them as one of the 4 best.   No one is going to scream for Louisville unless they are the only undefeated team.     Because they are NOT one of the best 10 teams in college football.
10/17/2013 11:12 AM
Of course that's the stated objective.

I would certainly think there would be a valid argument that some 1 loss teams were better/had better seasons than an unbeaten OSU, but in terms of the practicalities of what would actually happen, the only time an unbeaten OSU is being left out of a 4 team playoff by a selection committee is if there 4 other unbeatens from the Big 5.
10/17/2013 11:29 AM
Then I suppose this playoff system, which hasn't been used yet, is just as broken as the BCS model.   I, for one, want to see the 4 best teams not the team from a big conference that played Buffalo and San Diego State to ensure an unbeaten season.
of 28
All Forums > Gridiron Dynasty Football > College Football > Playoffs, a season early

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

Popular on WhatIfSports site: Baseball Simulation | College Basketball Game | College Football Game | Online Baseball Game | Hockey Simulation | NFL Picks | College Football Picks | Sports Games

© 1999-2014 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.