I think we all kind of feel that way. I was really happy the way my team started (Koufax, Drysdale), but as the draft rolled on, I kept having to make tough choices. Sure, I added T.Williams and Pesky with the '46 Dobson pick, but that also meant I didn't get '97 Pedro or '64 Howard (the other two picks I was considering at that time). Now, my catching is weak and my #3-4 SPs are Dennis Martinez and sub-200-inning Bret Saberhagen. I really wanted Fingers to anchor my bullpen, so the '81 Cooper pick pretty much means that I can't add Gehrig with my eventual '35 Murphy pick.
We could run this draft with the same people and the same nominated players and if just one person changed an early round pick, everybody's rosters would be very much different.