I've always favored a little looser job/qualification process than a stricter one...I don't want things to be too easy, and I certainly don't want to undermine the guys that have "made it" but it's pretty ridiculous. There are D1 teams in at least Tark and Knight (probably Phelan?) that have never had a human coach...I mean, c'mon now. Even from a business standpoint, I know I've stopped playing because of screwy D1 job requirements, and I was only trying to get a D prestiged D1 team, so would you rather ease up a bit and keep everyone happy, or have someone quit because they can't get to where they deservedly want to go?
I think at the bare minimum...if you have played D1 for at least 1 season in a particular world, you should ALWAYS be eligible for a D- prestige D1 team...ALWAYS.