Currently I am not using it . Using 4-3 . But with right personnel 5-2 worked fine as base D.
I am not sure why it works . It does give up high percentage of passes but not very many big plays .
However, I would recruit and grow excellent db's and starting outside lb's . So it seemed to me the extra dl would add pressure and my lb's and db's would get many turnovers. Obviously, the better your db's and lb's the better it would work.
I ran 5-2 against everything except Trips and Shotgun. Not 100 percent of the time though. But between 5-2 and Nickel I ran little else.
Like anything in this game, the trick is Recruiting the best you can and Growing them the best you can. Otherwise , no matter what formations you run you will never get your team to the top.
But I reiterate, if done right(and this applies to Any formations) , the 5-2 can win NC's.