Defensive Personal Foul negates TD? Topic

This doesn't seem right.  Next play was 1st and 0 from the 0.

4:04 2 2nd & 2   OFF: Pro-Set    DEF: 4-3

Defense lines up for a run. Jose Colon takes the handoff and rushes wide. Colon gets to the line. Colon breaks a tackle and runs into the end zone. 2 yards gain. PENALTY on IUP (Richard Moses), DefensivePersonalFoul. 0 yard Penalty added to the end of the play. 2 yards on the play, enforced at IUP 0.

24 14
7/27/2014 3:01 PM
Posted by brygold on 7/27/2014 3:01:00 PM (view original):
This doesn't seem right.  Next play was 1st and 0 from the 0.

4:04 2 2nd & 2   OFF: Pro-Set    DEF: 4-3

Defense lines up for a run. Jose Colon takes the handoff and rushes wide. Colon gets to the line. Colon breaks a tackle and runs into the end zone. 2 yards gain. PENALTY on IUP (Richard Moses), DefensivePersonalFoul. 0 yard Penalty added to the end of the play. 2 yards on the play, enforced at IUP 0.

24 14
The offensive player did not get into the endzone on the 4:04 penalty, he was barely outside it (but the SIM puts it on the 0).  The penalty was a spot foul, with an automatic first down.  The next pay was 1st and less than a yard (0) and less than a yard (again 0) to go.  It's very poorly written, but I think it's OK.
7/27/2014 5:12 PM
Posted by mgm0461 on 7/27/2014 5:12:00 PM (view original):
Posted by brygold on 7/27/2014 3:01:00 PM (view original):
This doesn't seem right.  Next play was 1st and 0 from the 0.

4:04 2 2nd & 2   OFF: Pro-Set    DEF: 4-3

Defense lines up for a run. Jose Colon takes the handoff and rushes wide. Colon gets to the line. Colon breaks a tackle and runs into the end zone. 2 yards gain. PENALTY on IUP (Richard Moses), DefensivePersonalFoul. 0 yard Penalty added to the end of the play. 2 yards on the play, enforced at IUP 0.

24 14
The offensive player did not get into the endzone on the 4:04 penalty, he was barely outside it (but the SIM puts it on the 0).  The penalty was a spot foul, with an automatic first down.  The next pay was 1st and less than a yard (0) and less than a yard (again 0) to go.  It's very poorly written, but I think it's OK.
He scored on the play......

Colon gets to the line. Colon breaks a tackle and runs into the end zone. 
7/27/2014 6:14 PM
Posted by brygold on 7/27/2014 6:14:00 PM (view original):
Posted by mgm0461 on 7/27/2014 5:12:00 PM (view original):
Posted by brygold on 7/27/2014 3:01:00 PM (view original):
This doesn't seem right.  Next play was 1st and 0 from the 0.

4:04 2 2nd & 2   OFF: Pro-Set    DEF: 4-3

Defense lines up for a run. Jose Colon takes the handoff and rushes wide. Colon gets to the line. Colon breaks a tackle and runs into the end zone. 2 yards gain. PENALTY on IUP (Richard Moses), DefensivePersonalFoul. 0 yard Penalty added to the end of the play. 2 yards on the play, enforced at IUP 0.

24 14
The offensive player did not get into the endzone on the 4:04 penalty, he was barely outside it (but the SIM puts it on the 0).  The penalty was a spot foul, with an automatic first down.  The next pay was 1st and less than a yard (0) and less than a yard (again 0) to go.  It's very poorly written, but I think it's OK.
He scored on the play......

Colon gets to the line. Colon breaks a tackle and runs into the end zone. 
As I said, it's poorly written.  If he had scored, it would have said Touchdown, like it did two plays later (that, or your team decided to take the spot foul just outside the goal line).
7/28/2014 10:35 AM
Touchdown, and the logic should have made the automatic decline call!
7/28/2014 12:29 PM
Posted by mgm0461 on 7/28/2014 10:35:00 AM (view original):
Posted by brygold on 7/27/2014 6:14:00 PM (view original):
Posted by mgm0461 on 7/27/2014 5:12:00 PM (view original):
Posted by brygold on 7/27/2014 3:01:00 PM (view original):
This doesn't seem right.  Next play was 1st and 0 from the 0.

4:04 2 2nd & 2   OFF: Pro-Set    DEF: 4-3

Defense lines up for a run. Jose Colon takes the handoff and rushes wide. Colon gets to the line. Colon breaks a tackle and runs into the end zone. 2 yards gain. PENALTY on IUP (Richard Moses), DefensivePersonalFoul. 0 yard Penalty added to the end of the play. 2 yards on the play, enforced at IUP 0.

24 14
The offensive player did not get into the endzone on the 4:04 penalty, he was barely outside it (but the SIM puts it on the 0).  The penalty was a spot foul, with an automatic first down.  The next pay was 1st and less than a yard (0) and less than a yard (again 0) to go.  It's very poorly written, but I think it's OK.
He scored on the play......

Colon gets to the line. Colon breaks a tackle and runs into the end zone. 
As I said, it's poorly written.  If he had scored, it would have said Touchdown, like it did two plays later (that, or your team decided to take the spot foul just outside the goal line).
I still don't understand how he didn't score if it says "runs into the endzone" but oh well.  He did score two plays later!
7/28/2014 2:28 PM
maybe the ball didn't cross the plane
7/28/2014 3:07 PM
Posted by wvufan76 on 7/28/2014 12:29:00 PM (view original):
Touchdown, and the logic should have made the automatic decline call!
This is a 100% true statement. He should have made the TD.

Put a ticket in and wait the 3 weeks before they give you and answer. If you get one.
7/28/2014 3:45 PM
3 weeks?!?! I'm still waiting on my Feb ticket regarding end of game timeout/clock mgmt logic.
7/28/2014 4:18 PM
LOL :-)
7/28/2014 10:45 PM
I checked my open ticket. In HBD. It will have its 1 year anniversary on August 18th. Status says In Progress.
7/28/2014 11:01 PM
Happened again last night!  I thought the play after was funny.  I'm pretty sure they made it clear Stubbs got in the endzone......

2:26 Own 48 1st & 10   OFF: Trips    DEF: Nickel
Defense lines up for a pass with a cover Long. Paul Stubbs takes the handoff and rushes wide. Stubbs makes his way to the outside. Stubbs breaks a tackle and runs into the end zone. 52 yards gain. PENALTY on UWO (Robert Espinoza), DefensivePersonalFoul. 0 yard Penalty added to the end of the play. 52 yards on the play, enforced at UWO 0.
0 30
2:18 0 1st & 0   OFF: Trips    DEF: 4-3

Defense lines up for a pass with a cover Medium. Paul Stubbs takes the handoff and rushes wide. Stubbs rushes through the middle all the way into the end zone. Stubbs gets a little help from the line to get to the outside and into the end zone. Stubbs gets into the end zone. 0 yards on the play. Stubbs breaks a tackle and runs into the end zone. 0 yards gain. TOUCHDOWN.

0 30
7/29/2014 8:31 AM
Also interesting to note that he did not get credit for the 52 yard gain in the stat sheet.
7/29/2014 8:34 AM
Defensive Personal Foul negates TD? Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2024 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.