I have a Catcher who is rated: Contact = 10, Power = 1, Speed = 5, Stamina = F. Defense rates at C/D/C+, and he bats L and throws R. I did the search and came up with 1930 Bennie Tate. The problem is that Tate apparently played for 2 teams in 1930 but has three sets of stats. The first two listed are the Washington Senators and the Chicago White Sox, and both have the same stats: 288 PA, .312 avg., .358 obp and .372 slg. But a little farther down on the results is a completely new entry for 1930 Tate, but it's still for the Chicago White Sox. Stats are different too: 267 PA, .317 avg., .367 obp and .383 slg. 1 man, 1 season, 2 teams, 3 results.
Does anyone know if there is a way to tell which version I have? All 3 are within the salary range for an Open League.