Progressive WifS league.. I need a 3B for 2013 and future (2012 roster had Wilson Betemit- missed nearly all of 2013 with knee injury and Jerry Hairston Jr.- missed nearly every pitch that was thrown to him).
I have "surplus" at SS with Andrelton Simmons and Asdrubal Cabrera or at OF with Trout, Soriano, Cuddyer, D Brown, C Crawford.
I've been offered David Freese for Soriano, or Matt Dominguez for Cabrera.
Freese is 30 and potentially on the decline already while Dominguez is 24 and presumably not at his peak yet. Dominguez is a decent fielder while Freese is brutal.
On the other hand, Freese is objectively better with the bat and I'd rather deal Soriano than Cabrera.