I have no doubt that at least one person believes that. I'll refer to the ol' saying of "The cream always rises to the top".
Lohse has proven, over the course of his career, to be a quite average pitcher. So, in this particular game, he might have recorded 19 outs via lasers hit right at someone. However, if history holds true, some of those 19 outs will become hits and Lohse will produce a line that's in line with his career numbers. Some of those hits may be of the blooper variety where Lohse threw a perfect pitch, even mediocre pitchers are capable of it, and the batter simply stuck his bat out.
For me, it's much easier to believe that things will always "even out" than for me to disregard, in this case, 86% of the game.