under all possible standards of equity (with the exception of possibly one, which is addressed below), seble is doing the right thing. he is re-simming the games and crediting anyone who ends up worse off with what they would have won. i expect that would include game credits, prestige bumps, reputation, etc.
the only plausible way to say this isn't "justified" or to choose to leave it as is, is if you believe that WIS should reward accidents above all else. because that's what happened...the dual sim was an accident. and if that's the standard, why are we wasting time gameplanning, setting rosters, exchanging ideas and strategies in the forums, etc.? for WIS to work at its best, according to this warped logic, everyone should set their depth charts and gameplans at the beginning of the season, sit back and let the chips fall where they may. if, however, we value user input and actual coaching, and there is a way to undo the accident (clearly there is and admin did a great job of addressing it promptly and coming up with the most equitable solution), that's what should be done.