Between this thread and the Cardale Jones thread, I can't figure for the life of me what criteria people judge QBs on. To my mind, an NFL QB has to do three things:
1/ Throw a great ball, accurately and with power.
2/ Work hard, learn offenses and defenses, show an advanced understanding and command of the playbook.
3/ Be an adult. Understand that fans want you to act like a leader, a professional, or at least not a jackoff.
ALL the guys who fail or even disappoint - everyone mentioned here except Luck and Wilson - fail in at least one of those areas.