realistically, I was hoping that collectively people would decide not to bother posting in this thread.....but that seems long ago and far away
for this to make any sense whatsoever, wouldn't you need to Sim the exact same circumstances with several different QBs?
comparing Brady with talent to Brady with crap tells no tale.....wouldn't you need to know how his performance with crap stood compared to others? by nature having Ability A perform with Talent B, C, and D and do well, but Ability A doing poorly with talent X, Y, and Z says more about Talents X, Y, and Z.
maybe Brady going 2-14 with the worst of the worst is still the best that any QB could do...obviously, I see what you are trying to do here, but your logic is incomplete...much like a 2007 Tom Brady pass thrown to Armless Jackson