I get the "D3 All-American" message on a lot of the players I recruit, and have had one D3 All-American. That shouldn't be an indication of the faultiness of the message as I don't run a system which would get rewarded by the All-American selection process (balanced scoring, try to be defensively based), but I do not think that it's a very useful message. Of course, I don't scout players that I don't already think are pretty good, so maybe my selection process is actually effective.