Now I have no idea (1) how much effort the D1 team had, or (2) why on earth an A- prestige D1 team wanted a guy that I would've considered a good D2 player. But it happened. . .

I think the fact that we now live in a post-fact era has a lot to do with it.

That's ridiculous I think! I have never seen such crappy ranked recruits in my life!!!!! So many with F grades for work ethic and some of the recruits could be d3 players......what a joke!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Human or Sim, and I am assuming it is at your Maryville Team?

Human, with College of New Jersey

I have beat some D1 Sims with nothing more than a few hundred APs some promises and a CV and/or HVs or 2.

I just defeated Vanderbilt (B) for a recruit. I was on him the whole time, guaranteed start. Vandy came 2nd cycle, but did offer a scholly.

D3 teams beating out D1 humans... nothing to see here.

"no idea (1) how much effort the D1 team had, or (2) why on earth an A- prestige D1 team wanted a guy that I would've considered a good D2 player"

No info here on which anyone can base any conclusions. Just stirring up the natives.

Posted by CoachSpud on 11/12/2016 4:16:00 PM (view original):
"no idea (1) how much effort the D1 team had, or (2) why on earth an A- prestige D1 team wanted a guy that I would've considered a good D2 player"

No info here on which anyone can base any conclusions. Just stirring up the natives.

so, the post was akin to Spud posts?

I guess I have been known to stir up the natives, eh?

If the D1 puts in enough effort to offer a scholarship and does, no way should a D3 school win. Ever.

Posted by reinsel on 11/12/2016 6:15:00 PM (view original):
If the D1 puts in enough effort to offer a scholarship and does, no way should a D3 school win. Ever.

... and since new coaches don't start at D1 ... and since WIS wants new coaches in some considerable number and wants to retain them in some considerable number, I think you are whistling down an empty well. It is already no more than the remotest of possibilities, but I don't think WIS will take it down to zero.

DI should have to only offer a scholarship to beat a DIII team. Anything else is absurd.

Let's just abolish the divisions. One giant mega divison! yeah! Thats fun!!