255M League Analysis Topic

Here is the breakdown of how many times each player was selected. Of the 96 owners, 63 selected Group A while 33 selected Group B.
.
Group A Group B
. Count . Count
Box1 . Addie Joss 2 Barry Bonds 5
Babe Ruth 22 Bob Gibson 1
Ed Walsh 3 Christy Mathewson 2
Greg Maddux 4 Dutch Leonard 0
Hugh Duffy 1 Ed Delahanty 1
Mordecai Brown 1 King Kelly 2
Nap Lajoie 4 Lou Gehrig 2
Pete Alexander 2 Mickey Mantle 0
Rogers Hornsby 0 Pedro Martinez 11
Silver King 14 Ted Williams 3
Tip O'Neill 0 Tris Speaker 0
Walter Johnson 10 Ty Cobb 6
.
Box2 Claude Hendrix 5 Arky Vaughan 4
Clayton Kershaw 12 Billy Hamilton 2
Eddie Cicotte 4 Elton Chamberlain 1
Harry Heilmann 2 George Brett 8
Jake Arrieta 8 George Sisler 2
Joe Jackson 1 Honus Wagner 1
Joe Morgan 4 Hughie Jennings 5
John McGraw 3 Jimmie Foxx 3
Lou Boudreau 4 Joe Dimaggio 0
Roger Connor 8 Lady Baldwin 1
Russ Ford 3 Sandy Koufax 5
Stan Musial 9 Tim Keefe 1
.
Box3 Babe Adams 12 Chief Bender 7
Dinelson Lamet 4 Cy Seymour 2
Ed Seward 8 Dan Brouthers 2
Ferdie Schupp 2 Don Sutton 1
Jacob deGrom 11 Ed Morris 0
Jeff Bagwell 2 Hack Wilson 0
Juan Soto 1 Kevin Brown 1
Mike Schmidt 0 Mike Piazza 3
Pete Browning 8 Norm Cash 0
Todd Helton 2 Rod Carew 3
Willie Keeler 3 Sam Thompson 3
Zack Greinke 10 Shane Bieber 11
.
Box4 Chuck Klein 4 Al Simmons 2
Dennis Eckersley 6 Bill Bernhard 0
Ed Reulbach 4 Bill Terry 2
Eddie Collins 11 Charlie Gehringer 3
Eddie Plank 3 Devin Williams 2
Eric Gagne 6 Doc White 1
Frank Thomas 4 Fred Toney 1
Jack Chesbro 2 Jesse Burkett 2
Jack Clements 6 Joe Kelley 5
Luke Appling 4 Joe Medwick 1
Tommy Tucker 3 Randy Johnson 5
Trevor Bauer 10 Willie Mays 9
.
Box5 Bill Dickey 3 Cap Anson 4
Chipper Jones 6 Chris Sale 4
Frank Baker 7 Corbin Burnes 3
Frankie Frisch 7 Fred Clarke 0
Jack Pfiester 3 Jocko Milligan 2
Jose Bautista 3 Kenny Lofton 1
Larry Walker 13 Lefty O'Doul 1
Mariano Rivera 4 Liam Hendriks 3
Paul Waner 0 Luis Tiant 1
Tony Gonsolin 3 Richie Ashburn 3
Wade Boggs 11 Ron Guidry 9
Willie McGee 3 Toad Ramsey 2
.
Box6 Benny Kauff 10 Albert Belle 3
Bill Lange 2 Albert Pujols 5
Corey Kluber 1 Cy Young 7
Cupid Childs 1 DJ LeMahieu 2
Edgar Martinez 4 Ernie Banks 1
Frank Smith 1 Hong-Chih Kuo 0
Fred Lynn 2 Joe Wood 1
Joe Mauer 11 Justin Verlander 11
Nomar Garciaparra 8 Koji Uehara 1
Tony Gwynn 7 Mike Trout 1
Troy Tulowitzki 10 Rickey Henderson 1
Vida Blue 6 Willie Wilson 0
.
Box7 Billy Wagner 5 Andrew Miller 0
Bruce Sutter 5 Art Nehf 7
Craig Kimbrel 13 Babe Herman 2
Dave McNally 3 Chris Martin 0
Dwight Gooden 3 Fernando Rodney 1
Heinie Manush 2 J.R. Richard 5
Jason Giambi 5 Johnny Niggeling 0
John Olerud 3 Jose Reyes 3
Mike Scott 10 Juan Marichal 5
Orval Overall 4 Lave Cross 4
Pete Reiser 5 Mark McGwire 6
Roger Clemens 5 Victor Gonzalez 0
.
Box8 Adrian Beltre 2 Al Rosen 8
Bill Joyce 6 Blake Treinen 3
Denny Lyons 4 Earl Averill 0
Freddie Freeman 7 Freddy Lindstrom 0
Joe Horlen 6 John Tudor 5
Joe Nathan 2 Kenta Maeda 8
Josh Hader 2 Kirby Puckett 1
Mookie Betts 9 Marco Scutaro 1
Nick Anderson 2 Mel Ott 1
Sammy Sosa 9 Pete Rose 3
Tim Raines 9 Trevor Rosenthal 2
Wade Davis 5 Willie McCovey 1
.
Box9 Alex Rodriguez 8 B.J. Ryan 3
Barney Pelty 1 Bernie Williams 2
Bill Dahlen 4 Charlie Buffinton 2
Brad Hand 4 Dean Chance 1
Heinie Zimmerman 2 Elston Howard 5
Jake Northrop 11 Frank Robinson 1
Jason Schmidt 3 Ichiro Suzuki 5
Johnny Bench 5 Jackie Robinson 5
Kenley Jansen 5 Jesse Hahn 1
Max Scherzer 5 Roberto Alomar 2
Paul O'Neill 6 Snuffy Stirnweiss 5
Zach Britton 9 Tuck Turner 1
.
Box10 Adam Kolarek 4 Dellin Betances 4
Derrek Lee 3 Henry Larkin 2
Emmanuel Clase 9 Ivan Rodriguez 2
Gus Weyhing 3 Jimmy Sheckard 2
Hank Aaron 10 Joey Devine 4
Joe Torre 5 Johan Santana 2
Jonathan Papelbon 7 Ke'Bryan Hayes 2
Luis Gonzalez 4 Mickey Cochrane 4
Rafael Betancourt 2 Mike Adams 2
Red Schoendienst 5 Ozzie Smith 4
Rich Gossage 10 Spencer Strider 3
Zac Gallen 1 Trevor Hoffman 2
.
Box11 Bryce Harper 10 Aaron Judge 5
Chad Green 5 Cal Ripken Jr. 3
Cla Meredith 12 Charlie Ferguson 1
Freddy Peralta 0 Christian Yelich 1
George McQuillan 4 Evan Phillips 3
Harry Krause 4 George Davis 2
Jesse Tannehill 2 George Stone 4
Ken Caminiti 9 Jake McGee 1
Miguel Cabrera 4 Jimmy Rollins 0
Norm Charlton 2 Keith Hernandez 0
Sean Doolittle 7 Ken Williams 6
Yu Darvish 4 Manny Ramirez 7
.
Box12 Buddy Myer 4 Carl Yastrzemski 5
Carlos Delgado 2 Dennis Rasmussen 1
Casey Sadler 2 Edwin Diaz 3
Cesar Valdez 9 Elmer Steele 3
Duke Snider 6 Gavvy Cravath 1
Jim Hearn 7 Harry Brecheen 1
Joe Cronin 10 Howie Pollet 2
Jose Altuve 5 J.J. Putz 6
Mike Napoli 11 Jake Diekman 0
Robb Nen 4 Kiki Cuyler 5
Salvador Perez 1 Steve Carlton 5
Tony Lazzeri 2 Tim Burke 1
.
Box13 Barry Larkin 7 Alex Colome 2
Buster Posey 10 Baker Bowl 1
Carl Hubbell 4 Bill George 4
Cisco Carlos 17 Brandon Workman 1
Joel Pineiro 2 Buck Ewing 7
Mike Griffin 3 Craig Biggio 1
Nick Maddox 2 Darin Erstad 5
Phil Cavarretta 1 Dave Davenport 3
Robin Yount 4 Don Padgett 1
Sergio Romo 3 Rick Wilkins 1
Stan Coveleski 1 Tito Francona 2
Takashi Saito 9 Tom Seaver 5
.
Box14 Andrew Bailey 9 Catfish Hunter 5
Bobby Jenks 3 Felix Hernandez 4
George Kell 0 John Shaffer 0
Hoyt Wilhelm 8 Lance Berkman 0
Jeff Reardon 1 Neftali Feliz 1
Joaquin Benoit 6 Rafael Soriano 12
Johnny Mize 19 Rob Murphy 3
Jose Fernandez 1 Ryan Helsley 2
Kirby Yates 5 Sergio Santos 0
Ryan Madson 2 Steve Karsay 0
Sam Crawford 3 Ted Simmons 3
Sherry Magee 6 Zach Plesac 3
.
Box15 Andre Dawson 1 Al Grabowski 1
Arthur Rhodes 8 Carlton Fisk 3
Brandon Morrow 4 Dale Murray 2
Chase Utley 8 Jake Weimer 1
Dave Smith 3 John Smoltz 6
Denny McLain 1 Jorge Posada 0
Freddy Sanchez 2 Jose LeClerc 4
Goose Goslin 17 Ketel Marte 5
Miguel Rojas 0 Kevin Saucier 0
Ralph Kiner 9 Placido Polanco 3
Roy Cullenbine 8 Target Field 7
Tommy Holmes 2 Yankee Stadium III 1
.
Box16 Darrell Porter 3 Alex Torres 0
Derek Jeter 2 Armando Benitez 0
Fred Carroll 8 Aroldis Chapman 7
Gerrit Cole 2 Bill Henry 5
Grant Balfour 4 Edd Roush 4
Jeff Kent 7 Eddie Mathews 4
Jeff Manship 8 Edgardo Alfonzo 0
Jeff Zimmerman 5 George Gore 0
Josh Hamilton 4 Hank Greenberg 7
Mark Teixeira 11 Nolan Arenado 3
Max Carey 7 Ryne Sandberg 2
Tom Niedenfuer 2 Tom Gordon 1
.
Box17 Babe Phelps 3 Bubbles Hargrave 3
Charlie Hickman 2 Busch Stadium 3
Felipe Rivero 3 Dick Wakefield 1
Greg Holland 9 Elvis Andrus 2
Hanley Ramirez 12 Gary Sanchez 1
Howie Camnitz 6 Jay Bell 0
Jack Harshman 0 Luis Avilan 1
Jack Taylor 6 Rafael Furcal 6
Lenny Dykstra 2 Rod Beck 2
Roger Bresnahan 6 Ted Abernathy 5
Steve Howe 6 Tony Fernandez 2
Zane Smith 8 Tyler Duffey 7
.
Box18 Codi Heuer 3 Dodger Stadium 2
Grant Jackson 0 Don Slaught 0
Hank Severeid 2 Eric Davis 3
Howard Johnson 5 Felipe Lopez 2
Joe Benz 3 Jack Quinn 5
Matt Williams 9 Jason Adam 1
Pop Corkhill 12 Mark Melancon 2
Possum Whitted 10 Matt Harvey 6
Ryan Tepera 3 Pat Neshek 1
Scott Rolen 6 Randy Winn 5
South Side Park (III) 2 Rheal Cormier 1
Willie Hernandez 8 Troy Percival 5
.
Box19 Astrodome 6 Bobby Abreu 2
Blake Snell 2 Byron Buxton 3
Bob Milacki 21 Carlos Rodon 2
Bret Saberhagen 2 Chris Hammond 1
Bryan Harvey 4 Dave Orr 3
Ernie Shore 1 David Robertson 8
Gabby Hartnett 5 Harry Walker 4
Lindy McDaniel 0 Ken Giles 3
Neal Cotts 4 Lew Fonseca 6
Reb Russell 6 Nolan Ryan 1
Rollie Fingers 9 Pete Conway 0
Tim McCabe 3 Yimi Garcia 0
.
Box20 Andres Galarraga 0 Andrew McCutchen 0
Ben Zobrist 6 Andrew Stevenson 1
Cy Morgan 6 Barry Latman 3
Dave Righetti 7 Bob Johnson 1
Elmer Smith 2 Earl Smith 2
George Dumont 5 Ellis Burks 4
Lloyd Waner 2 Frank Chance 1
Municipal Stadium 7 Jeff Cirillo 2
Rich Hill 14 Lew McCarty 4
Roberto Osuna 2 Oliver Perez 4
Roger Nelson 5 Oscar Gamble 3
Todd Haney 7 Rico Petrocelli 8
.
Box21 Al Kaline 6 AT&T Park 2
Buddy Groom 2 Billy Werber 3
Cesar Cedeno 17 Darren O'Day 4
Dick Allen 4 Jimmy Williams 0
Eddie Stanky 2 Lance Johnson 0
Fernando Abad 2 Mark Loretta 10
Fred Nicholson 3 Nellie Fox 5
Jarlin Garcia 3 Tanner Houck 0
Jarrod Dyson 2 Tiny Bonham 3
Javy Lopez 6 Todd Frohwirth 5
Mark Eichhorn 15 Todd Pratt 0
Roy Campanella 1 Warren Spahn 1
.
Box22 Burch Smith 4 Alan Trammell 2
Chief Meyers 4 Brandon Crawford 0
Chris Hoiles 5 Comiskey Park (I) 3
Dave Dellucci 1 Corey Seager 6
Earle Brucker 8 Derek Lowe 3
Geovany Soto 3 Duke Farrell 5
Joe Harris 0 Jack McDowell 7
Joey Votto 14 Joe Smith 5
Memorial Coliseum (LA) 6 Kevin Siegrist 0
Mike Donlin 1 Pedro Guerrero 1
Robin Roberts 5 Riggs Stephenson 1
Shane Spencer 12 Vean Gregg 0
.
Box23 Bobby Murcer 9 C.C. Sabathia 1
Brad Keller 1 Carmen Hill 4
Cecil Cooper 1 Frank Schwindel 3
Cecil Travis 8 Hal Woodeshick 0
Joe Thatcher 4 Hardy Richardson 1
Larry Doby 4 John Butcher 1
Livan Soto 6 Nestor Cortes 1
Octavio Dotel 10 Palace of the Fans 3
Phenomenal Smith 7 Roberto Clemente 4
Ranger Suarez 3 Roy Mitchell 3
Rich Aurilia 5 Steve Ontiveros 10
Tim Spooneybarger 5 Tug McGraw 2
.
Box24 Aaron Sanchez 2 Bake McBride 2
Bill Burgo 1 Bret Barberie 4
Brady Anderson 3 Christian Vazquez 0
Carlos Beltran 9 Eddie Perez 2
Cleveland Stadium 3 Eric Young 2
Dee Gordon 4 Harry Stovey 3
Gil McDougald 5 Jason Isringhausen 4
Jack Lapp 3 Jason Kendall 6
Jay Clarke 1 Ken Griffey Jr. 6
Joakim Soria 13 Kendall Graveman 2
Olympic Stadium 3 Ray Searage 1
Terry Shumpert 16 Reggie Jackson 1
.
Box25 Daniel Murphy 2 Rick Aguilera 1
Francisco Rodriguez 12 Andres Gimenez 1
Gates Brown 11 Ben Paschal 1
Jim Handiboe 3 Bob O'Farrell 5
Johnny Bassler 4 Carl Weilman 4
Johnny Pesky 5 Doug Henry 0
Jose Ramirez 3 Exhibition Stadium 3
Mike Gonzalez 1 Paul Blair 1
Pascual Perez 2 Robinson Cano 7
Shawn Armstrong 5 Ryan Brasier 1
Tony Phillips 12 Ryan Sherriff 5
Wrigley Field (LA) 3 Turner Ward 4
.
Box26 Andrew Chafin 6 Ed Cushman 1
Jefferson St Grounds 9 Frank Owen 1
Mickey Welch 1 Fred Snodgrass 1
Nationals Park 8 Great American Ballpark 2
Reese McGuire 3 Huston Street 8
Roger Freed 7 Kaufmann/Royals Stadium 5
Sam Huff 3 Phil Douglas 1
Sportsman Park (II) 3 PNC Park 0
Sportsman Park (III) 10 Shawon Dunston 0
Ted Kluszewski 3 Tim Lincecum 2
Tropicana Field 3 Trea Turner 3
Wally Schang 7 Zack Wheat 8
6/13/2023 12:00 AM (edited)
I can calculate what I call the "Cookie Score". This measures how popular the players are that you rostered. The higher the number, the more popular your selected players are. If you were the only person to take a player, in every box, your Cookie Score would be 1.00. Here is a list of every team, sorted by League, then by Salary. The average Cookie Score for Box A is 8.53 and for Box B is 5.04. The average salary for Box A is 177.3 million and for Box B is 181.9 million.
.
League . Owner . Box .... Cookie Score . Salary
--------- --------------- ------------ ------------ ----------------
6-A bullet6464 Box B 4.33 203,971,572
6-A thejuice6 Box A 9.01 198,196,604
6-A mattedesa Box B 5.38 197,781,413
6-A rmarksduke Box A 9.55 196,053,078
6-A gworear Box B 6.14 193,959,883
6-A ff09 Box A 6.15 187,000,109
6-A ledfoot Box B 4.47 184,008,681
6-A jbohrman Box A 9.54 179,212,692
6-A Bill_James47 Box A 8.64 178,155,400
6-A eblankenstei Box B 3.73 178,135,598
6-A tigerrott Box A 9.38 177,736,677
6-A skilly006 Box A 7.07 177,507,532
6-A Relkcirts Box A 6.16 176,713,899
6-A PrimetimeTW Box A 9.90 176,616,385
6-A mpitt76 Box A 6.48 176,451,926
6-A frank_drebin Box A 9.65 173,472,884
6-A boogerlips Box A 8.88 169,739,744
6-A ericmill16 Box A 6.21 167,915,636
6-A Jdh34 Box A 7.07 166,586,517
6-A buddhagamer Box A 8.96 166,497,835
6-A beauchamp Box A 8.22 163,055,055
6-A Ribbentrop Box A 10.35 160,809,366
6-A chargingryno Box B 4.86 159,619,744
6-A vaugheyj Box A 7.29 150,012,775
--------- --------------- --------- ------------ ----------------
6-B wstevens07 Box B 5.43 225,461,639
6-B dilligafdbp Box A 8.16 202,094,545
6-B mickr9 Box B 5.65 199,183,469
6-B markeking Box A 8.66 194,790,079
6-B fatboydad54 Box B 4.06 189,451,516
6-B brickster44 Box A 4.90 183,270,045
6-B ChitownBluz Box A 6.57 181,421,145
6-B adsmith182 Box B 5.68 179,321,903
6-B barracuda3 Box A 11.60 177,497,753
6-B mllama54 Box B 3.41 176,993,871
6-B redcped Box A 9.26 175,917,397
6-B 3dayrotation Box A 8.48 175,408,403
6-B jfranco77 Box A 9.91 173,809,043
6-B jmcraven74 Box B 6.70 172,868,185
6-B Taxman2008 Box A 6.76 172,851,214
6-B Quarantine Box A 9.28 169,127,485
6-B odalisgagne Box A 10.02 169,031,714
6-B SteveIzzy Box A 6.95 166,870,304
6-B BeAllEndAll Box A 11.79 166,782,694
6-B sford Box B 4.67 164,218,576
6-B d_rock97 Box A 10.15 163,672,862
6-B Fsmiley Box A 8.85 157,769,585
6-B newarkwilder Box A 6.00 153,307,811
6-B just4me Box A 9.62 152,965,383
--------- --------------- --------- ------------ ----------------
6-C donaldjtrump Box A 8.53 221,903,300
6-C franklynne Box B 3.71 204,060,113
6-C Fungoes Box B 4.17 199,711,462
6-C big_dowg Box A 7.04 198,562,036
6-C garmansouth Box A 8.11 197,736,816
6-C Sonofodin52 Box A 7.25 196,340,481
6-C AAartist3 Box A 8.67 194,942,955
6-C nordawg Box A 7.17 194,134,604
6-C alainacath Box B 5.66 190,195,341
6-C trd3 Box B 5.15 189,702,515
6-C magicdreamer Box B 4.66 187,083,999
6-C dorkster Box B 5.57 184,078,472
6-C ceno1515 Box A 7.25 183,396,980
6-C firesalt Box B 5.35 180,564,408
6-C besterateam Box A 9.84 179,894,939
6-C Galveston Box B 5.66 176,427,791
6-C mildnhazy Box B 6.14 172,206,185
6-C Tammyk Box A 5.86 169,469,684
6-C contrarian23 Box A 9.75 168,974,005
6-C justinlee_24 Box A 10.06 167,667,253
6-C duhbigcat Box A 10.13 163,705,849
6-C MJDSupporter Box B 5.67 159,733,881
6-C _JJP_ Box B 5.39 158,675,402
6-C ronthegenius Box B 3.98 148,360,977
--------- --------------- --------- ------------ ----------------
6-D blackicedcof Box A 8.02 224,207,798
6-D toysboys Box A 8.99 219,220,006
6-D schwarze Box A 10.17 199,635,157
6-D Fusion27s Box A 9.84 192,668,486
6-D GeorgeHRuth Box B 5.84 185,666,622
6-D calhoop Box B 4.22 184,257,468
6-D RebJebb Box B 4.38 184,186,137
6-D marinerrott Box A 9.16 182,626,069
6-D discodemo Box B 6.29 182,124,011
6-D asdlfef Box B 4.13 176,867,352
6-D hebdomad Box A 9.97 174,516,949
6-D cubbies84 Box A 9.73 174,415,861
6-D ejstockman Box A 9.00 173,321,988
6-D Bansberg Box B 4.61 173,305,334
6-D toddcommish Box B 5.98 172,762,354
6-D oldtimer59 Box A 9.60 172,411,924
6-D mjkrunner Box A 8.69 171,895,943
6-D doctorcc Box A 8.83 170,205,887
6-D Jtpsops Box B 5.39 168,095,000
6-D DCNats4000 Box A 9.84 161,920,832
6-D NebHusker Box A 7.43 161,490,283
6-D redsfive Box A 6.64 160,343,720
6-D billyb1173 Box A 7.99 160,022,334
6-D Qhadow123 Box A 8.58 155,640,955
6/13/2023 12:10 AM (edited)
This is the same table, sorted by Cookie Score...
.
League . Owner . Box ... Cookie Score . Salary
--------- --------------- ------------ ------------ ----------------
6-B BeAllEndAll Box A 11.79 166,782,694
6-B barracuda3 Box A 11.60 177,497,753
6-A Ribbentrop Box A 10.35 160,809,366
6-D schwarze Box A 10.17 199,635,157
6-B d_rock97 Box A 10.15 163,672,862
6-C duhbigcat Box A 10.13 163,705,849
6-C justinlee_24 Box A 10.06 167,667,253
6-B odalisgagne Box A 10.02 169,031,714
6-D hebdomad Box A 9.97 174,516,949
6-B jfranco77 Box A 9.91 173,809,043
6-A PrimetimeTW Box A 9.90 176,616,385
6-C besterateam Box A 9.84 179,894,939
6-D DCNats4000 Box A 9.84 161,920,832
6-D Fusion27s Box A 9.84 192,668,486
6-C contrarian23 Box A 9.75 168,974,005
6-D cubbies84 Box A 9.73 174,415,861
6-A frank_drebin Box A 9.65 173,472,884
6-B just4me Box A 9.62 152,965,383
6-D oldtimer59 Box A 9.60 172,411,924
6-A rmarksduke Box A 9.55 196,053,078
6-A jbohrman Box A 9.54 179,212,692
6-A tigerrott Box A 9.38 177,736,677
6-B Quarantine Box A 9.28 169,127,485
6-B redcped Box A 9.26 175,917,397
6-D marinerrott Box A 9.16 182,626,069
6-A thejuice6 Box A 9.01 198,196,604
6-D ejstockman Box A 9.00 173,321,988
6-D toysboys Box A 8.99 219,220,006
6-A buddhagamer Box A 8.96 166,497,835
6-A boogerlips Box A 8.88 169,739,744
6-B Fsmiley Box A 8.85 157,769,585
6-D doctorcc Box A 8.83 170,205,887
6-D mjkrunner Box A 8.69 171,895,943
6-C AAartist3 Box A 8.67 194,942,955
6-B markeking Box A 8.66 194,790,079
6-A Bill_James47 Box A 8.64 178,155,400
6-D Qhadow123 Box A 8.58 155,640,955
6-C donaldjtrump Box A 8.53 221,903,300
6-B 3dayrotation Box A 8.48 175,408,403
6-A beauchamp Box A 8.22 163,055,055
6-B dilligafdbp Box A 8.16 202,094,545
6-C garmansouth Box A 8.11 197,736,816
6-D blackicedcof Box A 8.02 224,207,798
6-D billyb1173 Box A 7.99 160,022,334
6-D NebHusker Box A 7.43 161,490,283
6-A vaugheyj Box A 7.29 150,012,775
6-C ceno1515 Box A 7.25 183,396,980
6-C Sonofodin52 Box A 7.25 196,340,481
6-C nordawg Box A 7.17 194,134,604
6-A skilly006 Box A 7.07 177,507,532
6-A Jdh34 Box A 7.07 166,586,517
6-C big_dowg Box A 7.04 198,562,036
6-B SteveIzzy Box A 6.95 166,870,304
6-B Taxman2008 Box A 6.76 172,851,214
6-D redsfive Box A 6.64 160,343,720
6-B ChitownBluz Box A 6.57 181,421,145
6-A mpitt76 Box A 6.48 176,451,926
6-A ericmill16 Box A 6.21 167,915,636
6-A Relkcirts Box A 6.16 176,713,899
6-A ff09 Box A 6.15 187,000,109
6-B newarkwilder Box A 6.00 153,307,811
6-C Tammyk Box A 5.86 169,469,684
6-B brickster44 Box A 4.90 183,270,045
--------- --------------- --------- ------------ ----------------
6-B jmcraven74 Box B 6.70 172,868,185
6-D discodemo Box B 6.29 182,124,011
6-A gworear Box B 6.14 193,959,883
6-C mildnhazy Box B 6.14 172,206,185
6-D toddcommish Box B 5.98 172,762,354
6-D GeorgeHRuth Box B 5.84 185,666,622
6-B adsmith182 Box B 5.68 179,321,903
6-C MJDSupporter Box B 5.67 159,733,881
6-C alainacath Box B 5.66 190,195,341
6-C Galveston Box B 5.66 176,427,791
6-B mickr9 Box B 5.65 199,183,469
6-C dorkster Box B 5.57 184,078,472
6-B wstevens07 Box B 5.43 225,461,639
6-D Jtpsops Box B 5.39 168,095,000
6-C _JJP_ Box B 5.39 158,675,402
6-A mattedesa Box B 5.38 197,781,413
6-C firesalt Box B 5.35 180,564,408
6-C trd3 Box B 5.15 189,702,515
6-A chargingryno Box B 4.86 159,619,744
6-B sford Box B 4.67 164,218,576
6-C magicdreamer Box B 4.66 187,083,999
6-D Bansberg Box B 4.61 173,305,334
6-A ledfoot Box B 4.47 184,008,681
6-D RebJebb Box B 4.38 184,186,137
6-A bullet6464 Box B 4.33 203,971,572
6-D calhoop Box B 4.22 184,257,468
6-C Fungoes Box B 4.17 199,711,462
6-D asdlfef Box B 4.13 176,867,352
6-B fatboydad54 Box B 4.06 189,451,516
6-C ronthegenius Box B 3.98 148,360,977
6-A eblankenstei Box B 3.73 178,135,598
6-C franklynne Box B 3.71 204,060,113
6-B mllama54 Box B 3.41 176,993,871
6/13/2023 12:09 AM
I was the only one who took Chamberlain? Surprising.
6/13/2023 8:21 AM
Interesting that the cookie scores in Group B are far lower on average than those in Group A.
6/13/2023 10:15 AM
Teams sorted by salary:
League . Owner . Box ... Cookie Score . Salary
--------- --------------- --------- ------------ ----------------
--------- --------------- ------------ ------------ ----------------
6-B wstevens07 Box B 5.43 225,461,639
6-D blackicedcof Box A 8.02 224,207,798
6-C donaldjtrump Box A 8.53 221,903,300
6-D toysboys Box A 8.99 219,220,006
6-C franklynne Box B 3.71 204,060,113
6-A bullet6464 Box B 4.33 203,971,572
6-B dilligafdbp Box A 8.16 202,094,545
6-C Fungoes Box B 4.17 199,711,462
6-D schwarze Box A 10.17 199,635,157
6-B mickr9 Box B 5.65 199,183,469
6-C big_dowg Box A 7.04 198,562,036
6-A thejuice6 Box A 9.01 198,196,604
6-A mattedesa Box B 5.38 197,781,413
6-C garmansouth Box A 8.11 197,736,816
6-C Sonofodin52 Box A 7.25 196,340,481
6-A rmarksduke Box A 9.55 196,053,078
6-C AAartist3 Box A 8.67 194,942,955
6-B markeking Box A 8.66 194,790,079
6-C nordawg Box A 7.17 194,134,604
6-A gworear Box B 6.14 193,959,883
6-D Fusion27s Box A 9.84 192,668,486
6-C alainacath Box B 5.66 190,195,341
6-C trd3 Box B 5.15 189,702,515
6-B fatboydad54 Box B 4.06 189,451,516
6-C magicdreamer Box B 4.66 187,083,999
6-A ff09 Box A 6.15 187,000,109
6-D GeorgeHRuth Box B 5.84 185,666,622
6-D calhoop Box B 4.22 184,257,468
6-D RebJebb Box B 4.38 184,186,137
6-C dorkster Box B 5.57 184,078,472
6-A ledfoot Box B 4.47 184,008,681
6-C ceno1515 Box A 7.25 183,396,980
6-B brickster44 Box A 4.9 183,270,045
6-D marinerrott Box A 9.16 182,626,069
6-D discodemo Box B 6.29 182,124,011
6-B ChitownBluz Box A 6.57 181,421,145
6-C firesalt Box B 5.35 180,564,408
6-C besterateam Box A 9.84 179,894,939
6-B adsmith182 Box B 5.68 179,321,903
6-A jbohrman Box A 9.54 179,212,692
6-A Bill_James47 Box A 8.64 178,155,400
6-A eblankenstei Box B 3.73 178,135,598
6-A tigerrott Box A 9.38 177,736,677
6-A skilly006 Box A 7.07 177,507,532
6-B barracuda3 Box A 11.6 177,497,753
6-B mllama54 Box B 3.41 176,993,871
6-D asdlfef Box B 4.13 176,867,352
6-A Relkcirts Box A 6.16 176,713,899
6-A PrimetimeTW Box A 9.9 176,616,385
6-A mpitt76 Box A 6.48 176,451,926
6-C Galveston Box B 5.66 176,427,791
6-B redcped Box A 9.26 175,917,397
6-B 3dayrotation Box A 8.48 175,408,403
6-D hebdomad Box A 9.97 174,516,949
6-D cubbies84 Box A 9.73 174,415,861
6-B jfranco77 Box A 9.91 173,809,043
6-A frank_drebin Box A 9.65 173,472,884
6-D ejstockman Box A 9 173,321,988
6-D Bansberg Box B 4.61 173,305,334
6-B jmcraven74 Box B 6.7 172,868,185
6-B Taxman2008 Box A 6.76 172,851,214
6-D toddcommish Box B 5.98 172,762,354
6-D oldtimer59 Box A 9.6 172,411,924
6-C mildnhazy Box B 6.14 172,206,185
6-D mjkrunner Box A 8.69 171,895,943
6-D doctorcc Box A 8.83 170,205,887
6-A boogerlips Box A 8.88 169,739,744
6-C Tammyk Box A 5.86 169,469,684
6-B Quarantine Box A 9.28 169,127,485
6-B odalisgagne Box A 10.02 169,031,714
6-C contrarian23 Box A 9.75 168,974,005
6-D Jtpsops Box B 5.39 168,095,000
6-A ericmill16 Box A 6.21 167,915,636
6-C justinlee_24 Box A 10.06 167,667,253
6-B SteveIzzy Box A 6.95 166,870,304
6-B BeAllEndAll Box A 11.79 166,782,694
6-A Jdh34 Box A 7.07 166,586,517
6-A buddhagamer Box A 8.96 166,497,835
6-B sford Box B 4.67 164,218,576
6-C duhbigcat Box A 10.13 163,705,849
6-B d_rock97 Box A 10.15 163,672,862
6-A beauchamp Box A 8.22 163,055,055
6-D DCNats4000 Box A 9.84 161,920,832
6-D NebHusker Box A 7.43 161,490,283
6-A Ribbentrop Box A 10.35 160,809,366
6-D redsfive Box A 6.64 160,343,720
6-D billyb1173 Box A 7.99 160,022,334
6-C MJDSupporter Box B 5.67 159,733,881
6-A chargingryno Box B 4.86 159,619,744
6-C _JJP_ Box B 5.39 158,675,402
6-B Fsmiley Box A 8.85 157,769,585
6-D Qhadow123 Box A 8.58 155,640,955
6-B newarkwilder Box A 6 153,307,811
6-B just4me Box A 9.62 152,965,383
6-A vaugheyj Box A 7.29 150,012,775
6-C ronthegenius Box B 3.98 148,360,977

Box A average salary: $177,295,153
Box B average salary: $181,910,330

Box A average cookie score: 8.53
Box B average cookie score: 5.04
6/13/2023 11:14 AM
Only 12 players not taken at all in Group A. I'm pretty surprised Hornsby is one of them.
6/13/2023 11:41 AM
Feel really good about my cookie score / salary ratio...
6/13/2023 1:33 PM
Posted by Jtpsops on 6/13/2023 10:15:00 AM (view original):
Interesting that the cookie scores in Group B are far lower on average than those in Group A.
If I'm reading schwarze explanation correctly it's because group A was chosen more than group B.
6/13/2023 2:28 PM
Interesting stuff. I went with column B. Scientific choice. I was watching Aladdin with my 4 year old and Robin Williams sang "Try all of Column B" in Friend Like Me so I went with it. I think I ended up ok. I only have two low picks where I was the only one who picked them and most of my picks are top 2/3, The two were low IP relievers.
6/14/2023 10:13 PM
Posted by Jtpsops on 6/13/2023 10:15:00 AM (view original):
Interesting that the cookie scores in Group B are far lower on average than those in Group A.
This makes perfect sense. There are fewer teams in Group B. Since the cookie score is based on how many times a player was picked, it has to be lower. To get the scores between A and B to be comparable, divide the score by the number teams.

When you take the average cookie score divided by the number of teams, Group B's number is slightly higher than Group A, meaning that there was less variability in the selections in Group B than in Group A.
6/20/2023 11:38 AM (edited)
I went group B because it had Gavvy Cravath. That was the only determining factor
6/22/2023 9:51 AM
Really interesting stuff. Curious to see whether a higher cookie score translates to a better record.
6/22/2023 11:05 PM
I added a tab to the Standings spreadsheet with data on the 255M league. So far, Box A is doing a bit better than Box B. I also ran a regression on the Cookie Score. For Box A, the correlation was slightly positive (higher cookie score = higher winning%), but for Box B, the correlation was essentially zero.

Also, the tab shows that the AL West (lowest salaries) has a better overall win% than the NL East (highest salaries).
6/29/2023 11:03 AM
Be interesting to see how the Ruth teams are doing overall.
7/10/2023 4:17 PM
12 Next ▸
255M League Analysis Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2024 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.