Week 5 Fantasy Football Projections From WhatIfSports.com image

Week 5 Fantasy Football Rankings

Fantasy football projections, predictions and cheat sheets
By Paul Bessire, WhatIfSports.com
October 6th, 2009

This thorough analysis and statistical evaluation of every player and team in the NFL is part of a broader endeavor with FOXSports.com's Fantasy Football. Each regular season game is simulated 10,001 times. This allows us to account for every player and statistical interaction in an NFL game. Rosters and depth charts are up-to-date and as accurate as possible as of Tuesday each week. Information on scoring appears at the bottom of this article.

To view a pop-up with positional rankings, please click on one of the links below. Good luck this season!

Quarterback Running Back Wide Receiver Tight End
Kicker Team Defense Individual Defense

1.Peyton ManningQBColtsTitans23.4
2.Matt SchaubQBTexansCardinals20.6
3.Adrian PetersonRBVikingsRams19.1
4.Kurt WarnerQBCardinalsTexans18.9
5.Rashard MendenhallRBSteelersLions18.3
6.Joe FlaccoQBRavensBengals18.1
7.Eli ManningQBGiantsRaiders16.9
8.Ben RoethlisbergerQBSteelersLions16.1
9.Trent EdwardsQBBillsBrowns15.8
10.Ronnie BrownRBDolphinsJets15.5
11.Shaun HillQB49ersFalcons15.3
12.Brett FavreQBVikingsRams15.1
13.Donovan McNabbQBEaglesBuccaneers15.0
14.Tom BradyQBPatriotsBroncos14.8
15.Chris JohnsonRBTitansColts14.8
16.David GarrardQBJaguarsSeahawks14.8
17.Seneca WallaceQBSeahawksJaguars14.4
18.Glen CoffeeRB49ersFalcons14.4
19.Tashard ChoiceRBCowboysChiefs14.3
20.Tim HightowerRBCardinalsTexans14.2
21.Steven JacksonRBRamsVikings14.2
22.Fred JacksonRBBillsBrowns14.2
23.Matt RyanQBFalcons49ers14.2
24.Maurice Jones-DrewRBJaguarsSeahawks14.1
25.Jason CampbellQBRedskinsPanthers14.1
26.Tony RomoQBCowboysChiefs14.1
27.Clinton PortisRBRedskinsPanthers14.0
28.Joseph AddaiRBColtsTitans13.8
29.Ray RiceRBRavensBengals13.4
30.Steve SlatonRBTexansCardinals13.3
31.Brandon JacobsRBGiantsRaiders13.1
32.Marion BarberRBCowboysChiefs13.1
33.Jerome HarrisonRBBrownsBills13.1
34.Steve SmithWRGiantsRaiders13.0
35.Cedric BensonRBBengalsRavens12.9
36.Mark SanchezQBJetsDolphins12.8
37.Reggie WayneWRColtsTitans12.6
38.Carnell WilliamsRBBuccaneersEagles12.3
39.Carson PalmerQBBengalsRavens12.3
40.Larry FitzgeraldWRCardinalsTexans12.2
41.Derek AndersonQBBrownsBills12.1
42.Michael TurnerRBFalcons49ers12.1
43.Brian WestbrookRBEaglesBuccaneers11.9
44.Jerricho CotcheryWRJetsDolphins11.8
45.DeAngelo WilliamsRBPanthersRedskins11.7
46.Kyle OrtonQBBroncosPatriots11.7
47.LeSean McCoyRBEaglesBuccaneers11.5
48.Daunte CulpepperQBLionsSteelers11.5
49.Matt CasselQBChiefsCowboys11.5
50.Andre JohnsonWRTexansCardinals11.5
51.Knowshon MorenoRBBroncosPatriots11.5
52.Ahmad BradshawRBGiantsRaiders11.1
53.Dallas ClarkTEColtsTitans10.8
54.Josh JohnsonQBBuccaneersEagles10.6
55.Randy MossWRPatriotsBroncos10.4
56.Marshawn LynchRBBillsBrowns10.2
57.Mohamed MassaquoiWRBrownsBills10.0
58.Jeff ReedKSteelersLions9.9
59.T.J. HoushmandzadehWRSeahawksJaguars9.8
60.Julius JonesRBSeahawksJaguars9.7
61.Chad OchocincoWRBengalsRavens9.7
62.Derrick MasonWRRavensBengals9.6
63.Mewelde MooreRBSteelersLions9.6
64.Kevin SmithRBLionsSteelers9.5
65.Kerry CollinsQBTitansColts9.4
66.Adam VinatieriKColtsTitans9.4
67.Jake DelhommeQBPanthersRedskins9.4
68.Larry JohnsonRBChiefsCowboys9.3
69.Nick FolkKCowboysChiefs9.3
70.Thomas JonesRBJetsDolphins9.3
72.Brandon MarshallWRBroncosPatriots9.2
73.Hines WardWRSteelersLions9.2
74.Calvin JohnsonWRLionsSteelers9.1
76.Brent CelekTEEaglesBuccaneers8.8
77.Neil RackersKCardinalsTexans8.8
78.Jonathan StewartRBPanthersRedskins8.8
79.Mike Sims-WalkerWRJaguarsSeahawks8.7
80.Chris CooleyTERedskinsPanthers8.7
81.Ryan LongwellKVikingsRams8.6
82.DeSean JacksonWREaglesBuccaneers8.5
83.Mark ClaytonWRRavensBengals8.5
84.Michael BushRBRaidersGiants8.5
85.Kris BrownKTexansCardinals8.4
86.Steve SmithWRPanthersRedskins8.4
87.Chad HenneQBDolphinsJets8.1
88.Santana MossWRRedskinsPanthers8.1
89.Jay FeelyKJetsDolphins8.0
90.Lawrence TynesKGiantsRaiders8.0
91.Leon WashingtonRBJetsDolphins8.0
92.Stephen GostkowskiKPatriotsBroncos7.9
93.Vernon DavisTE49ersFalcons7.9
94.Beanie WellsRBCardinalsTexans7.9
95.Kyle BollerQBRamsVikings7.9
96.Percy HarvinWRVikingsRams7.9
97.Roddy WhiteWRFalcons49ers7.8
98.Josh ScobeeKJaguarsSeahawks7.8
99.David AkersKEaglesBuccaneers7.8
100.Rian LindellKBillsBrowns7.7
101.Jamal LewisRBBrownsBills7.6
102.John KasayKPanthersRedskins7.6
103.Jason WittenTECowboysChiefs7.6
104.Olindo MareKSeahawksJaguars7.6
105.Terrell OwensWRBillsBrowns7.6
106.Wes WelkerWRPatriotsBroncos7.6
107.Steve BreastonWRCardinalsTexans7.5
108.Rashad JenningsRBJaguarsSeahawks7.5
109.Rob BironasKTitansColts7.5
110.Justin FargasRBRaidersGiants7.4
111.Pierre GarconWRColtsTitans7.3
112.Chester TaylorRBVikingsRams7.3
113.Anquan BoldinWRCardinalsTexans7.3
114.Kenny BrittWRTitansColts7.2
115.Sammy MorrisRBPatriotsBroncos7.1
116.Josh MorganWR49ersFalcons7.0
117.Jason HansonKLionsSteelers7.0
118.Lee EvansWRBillsBrowns7.0
119.Owen DanielsTETexansCardinals7.0
120.Fred TaylorRBPatriotsBroncos6.9
121.Shayne GrahamKBengalsRavens6.9
122.Billy CundiffKBrownsBills6.9
123.Shaun SuishamKRedskinsPanthers6.8
125.Greg JonesRBJaguarsSeahawks6.8
126.Dan CarpenterKDolphinsJets6.8
127.Donald BrownRBColtsTitans6.7
128.Willis McGaheeRBRavensBengals6.7
129.Joe NedneyK49ersFalcons6.6
130.JaMarcus RussellQBRaidersGiants6.5
131.Matt PraterKBroncosPatriots6.5
132.Steven HauschkaKRavensBengals6.5
133.Ricky WilliamsRBDolphinsJets6.5
134.Tony GonzalezTEFalcons49ers6.5
135.Isaac BruceWR49ersFalcons6.4
136.Kevin WalterWRTexansCardinals6.4
137.Michael JenkinsWRFalcons49ers6.4
138.Bernard BerrianWRVikingsRams6.4
142.Nate BurlesonWRSeahawksJaguars6.1
143.Santonio HolmesWRSteelersLions6.0
144.Ryan SuccopKChiefsCowboys5.9
145.Mario ManninghamWRGiantsRaiders5.9
148.Jason ElamKFalcons49ers5.9
151.Josh BrownKRamsVikings5.8
153.Sebastian JanikowskiKRaidersGiants5.8
156.Sidney RiceWRVikingsRams5.5
157.John CarlsonTESeahawksJaguars5.5
158.Heath MillerTESteelersLions5.5
159.Kevin BossTEGiantsRaiders5.5
160.Mark BradleyWRChiefsCowboys5.5
161.Bobby EngramWRChiefsCowboys5.4
162.Torry HoltWRJaguarsSeahawks5.3
163.Nate WashingtonWRTitansColts5.3
165.Austin CollieWRColtsTitans5.2
166.Moran NorrisRB49ersFalcons5.2
167.Muhsin MuhammadWRPanthersRedskins5.2
169.Davone BessWRDolphinsJets5.0
171.Dwayne BoweWRChiefsCowboys4.9
172.Kevin FaulkRBPatriotsBroncos4.9
174.Louis MurphyWRRaidersGiants4.9
176.Bernard ScottRBBengalsRavens4.8
177.Shonn GreeneRBJetsDolphins4.8
178.Todd HeapTERavensBengals4.8
179.Shane AndrusKBuccaneersEagles4.8
180.Sam HurdWRCowboysChiefs4.7
181.Jerious NorwoodRBFalcons49ers4.7
182.Chris JenningsRBBrownsBills4.7
183.Le'Ron McClainRBRavensBengals4.6
184.Greg CamarilloWRDolphinsJets4.5
185.Patrick CraytonWRCowboysChiefs4.5
186.Marcedes LewisTEJaguarsSeahawks4.5
187.Zach MillerTERaidersGiants4.4
188.Dustin KellerTEJetsDolphins4.4
190.Michael ClaytonWRBuccaneersEagles4.3
191.Earnest GrahamRBBuccaneersEagles4.3
192.Miles AustinWRCowboysChiefs4.3
194.Mike WallaceWRSteelersLions4.2
195.Jabar GaffneyWRBroncosPatriots4.2
196.Keenan BurtonWRRamsVikings4.2
197.Antonio BryantWRBuccaneersEagles4.2
199.Jerheme UrbanWRCardinalsTexans4.1
200.Hakeem NicksWRGiantsRaiders4.1

* The individual players and defensive teams are ranked based entirely on projected full-season fantasy points using the FOX Fantasy Football default scoring where for QBs, RBs, WRs and TE, all TDs are 6 points, each 25 yards passing are 1 point, interceptions are -2 points, fumbles lost are -2 points, each ten yards receiving are 1 point and two-point conversions are 2 points. For kickers, all extra points are 1 point and all field goals are at least 3 points with an extra bonus point for field goals made over 40 yards and another bonus point for field goals made over 50 yards. Individual defensive players (linked to below, but not inlcuded in overall rankings) earn 1 point for each solo tackle, 1 point for each sack, 2 points for each interception and six points for each touchdown. Team defenses include special teams and are treated similarly for sacks, interceptions and touchdown returns, while a more complex system, based on the outcome of each individual game, is utilized for points allowed per game.

Please note: These overall fantasy rankings are based on total points earned for the season. They do not account for position scarcity, number of owners drafting and their drafting styles, roster restrictions, custom league scoring rules or other items that should be considered while drafting.

Want to know how the best players of today would do against the greats of all-time? Find out using SimMatchup or build a team of the best ever and compete gainst others in the SimLeagues.

Paul Bessire is the Product Manager of Content and Quantitative Analysis for WhatIfSports.com, a division of FOX Sports Interactive specializing in fantasy football simulation analysis and football sim games. With any comments, questions or topic suggestions, Paul can be reached at BtB@whatifsports.com. Thanks!

SimLeague Football

Compete in a full season with your dream team from NFL past and present. Depth charts, game plans, prizes, and more.

Try It For Free


Create or re-play any fantasy matchup from sports history. One click yields a free box score and play-by-play.

Try It For Free

Hardball Dynasty

Run your own baseball franchise in this in-depth, multi-player baseball game.

Try It at a Discount

What is WhatIfSports?

WhatIfSports.com is a sports simulation and online gaming site providing free content and unique games for the MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, NCAA sports and more.

Join WhatIfSports.com today to get these members only benefits:

  • Create your own Dream Team
  • Save your favorite SimMatchup results
  • Play a FREE SimLeague trial season
  • Start playing a Dynasty game
  • Manage baseball games LIVE
  • Access to SiteMail
  • Post in our Forums
  • Build a Buddy list to easily invite friends
  • Use our online Customer Service
  • Earn game credits by using our Referral & Affiliate program

New Terms of Use Customer Support New Privacy Statement Advertising Choices

© 1999-2017 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. Use of this website (including any and all parts and components) constitutes your acceptance of these Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.