No, the original argument is "I don't need to watch games, I have stats."
It's the secondary argument that I agree about with regards to the course of a season/career. I could go back and find where I pointed out, in individual games/situations, "an out is an out" is stupid. Because, in specific instances, it's just not true. I'm pretty sure, in that post, I pointed out that you're arguing season/career while no one else is.
And, in a more recent post, I noted that you only care if a player's WAR makes him HOF-worthy. That individual games do not matter to you. I think, for the rest of us, we're far more invested in a game, series or even a season than you are. So you firmly believe you're right. And, to an extent, you are because you're making a different argument. I doubt, over the course of a career, that a guy who strikes out every 14 AB is going to have a much higher ROE rate than a guy who strikes out every 4.5 AB. But, in a game or series, he might reach base twice on error while the other guy just totes his bat to the dugout after another whiff.