for what its worth, ive heard this theory several times, that the pulldown point is different from the considering point. with undecided recruits, i don't believe thats true, i've tried too many incremental 1-2SV/1HV cycles to buy that (then again, it could have changed, this is years ago). minimally, i think that gap is very small. for players already considering a school, i absolutely think killbatman is right, you are able to recruit a player straight away before the considering point (assuming the other school has a lot of effort in). however, i also think killbatman's comments, which i believe are generally the most accurate and insightful in this thread, omit an occurrence which i do believe exists - where multiple people try to pull a recruit down, the recruit considers nobody, yet both coaches have sent upwards of 20 SVs and try HVs and they still do not work. its been so long its hard to say for sure, but im almost positive i experienced this myself, after being suspicious of a number of reports on the forums. i think what makes the finer points of pulldowns so complex are these two caveats - but i think they are in fact two distinct caveats, not just one - where players already considering someone, and players being pulled down by 2 schools simultaneously, behave differently than "normal" pulldowns. they seem to take more effort to pull down, despite considering no one. i also think for schools already considering someone, the "pulldown point" can be (but isn't always) different than the regular pulldown point, but i'm not sure about that.
Attempting to get back on track, I wanted to respond to something in this paragraph. I bolded the sentence above.
I freely admit this might exist and I haven't really seen it personally, but this does NOT match my experience. I can remember a fair number of times, as a D3 school, where myself and another coach pulled down a player at the same time and both showed up. Comparing notes afterwards, we both used the same 10SV+offer. I can remember a few where it was 13SV vs 10SV and both still showed up at the same time. I've read the 'escalating with 2 teams' scenario on the forums before, but just haven't seen that myself.