Posted by fd343ny on 6/14/2016 11:56:00 AM (view original):
my personal brand of negativity is much less about how well it functions and much more about whether its intended function (if done reasonably well) is useful
assume all the bugs and misplaced or badly implemented features are fixed
it still
a. doesnt fix whats broke
b. will demand a lot more effort to play
it is hard to argue with this one. although maybe it will make up for the awful recruit gen somehow magically, just by sheer volume of change. at least, i'm not confident enough to rule it out yet.
agree w/ tanner and OR though. constructive criticism is good, but i certainly would not categorize all of what is going on as constructive. my opinion is the update as it is today would kill HD, and im sure others feel that way, so maybe its appropriate in that sense to throw tantrums in hope seble backs out, but i think there is extremely little chance of that working. when seble announced this, there was quite an uproar, and that did nothing to dissuade him, at this point he's fully invested and i can't see him turning back. i don't agree the new system will be no skill though, i strongly suspect some coaches will find a way to win consistently.
6/14/2016 5:33 PM (edited)