This was taken from my old GD philosophy. Things may have changed but hope this helps.
BOOSTER GIFTS ( HOW TO AND WHICH RECRUITS WILL ACCEPT THEM)
OK, First I have to preface this with the fact that I have never used Booster Gifts. I have tried it once or twice but they were not accepted. I wanted to try and see what would happen based on what I have learned from a couple coach's I talked to that use them on a regular basis. Most of this info is from Steve Hoggett. He was pretty successful with them even at Notre Dame. Used right he said you have less than a 10% chance of getting investigated.
Keep in mind if you do get caught using them your Reputation can drop to F making recruiting more difficult and taking a lot longer to move up.
He told me what you look for in Scouting reports to figure out if the recruit may be open to receiving them are a preponderance of negative things in the report such as
Extremely bad temper -- he can't always control himself.
He's not about making sacrifices for the team.
Practically lives at the strip clubs
He's all about the bling
When the groupies come calling, he answers every time.
If we played with a hamburger instead of a pigskin, he'd be an all-star.
Things like this. You are probably not going to have a report with all negatives but here are a couple examples of players that might accept gifts.
1. Above average potential.
Looks a little turned off by practice.
Doesn't like getting shown up out there
He gets very jealous when other players are in the spotlight.
Practically lives at the strip clubs
It takes a lot to get him fired up.
He's not about making sacrifices for the team.
A little more restraint in the buffet line would be nice.
2. Looks like he has a hard time making adjustments.
Looks a little turned off by practice.
Can he keep his ego in check?
Seemed to be pretty jealous of his roommate's new car
Seems committed to his long-time girlfriend
His temper tends to get the best of him.
He plays for the love of the game.
If we played with a hamburger instead of a pigskin, he'd be an all-star.
I don't think this guy would even consider it and would get upset.
Looks like he has a hard time making adjustments.
He's got the work ethic to make strides as an athlete.
Doesn't show much pride in his accomplishments.
He's happy for his teammates when they succeed.
Seems committed to his long-time girlfriend
Doesn't seem to have a temper
He doesn't ask for much, just what he needs.
He recommended using the car stereo. If you use better things the likelihood of being investigated increases.
http://whatifsports.com/forums/Posts.aspx?TopicID=388658