I am voting for Arfy, because I know for a fact that I'm the vigilante. I made a huge mistake in trying to take out the mafia first night, something that would never happen to a player in arfy who knows from three games of experience that that wouldn't be the wisest choice. I chose to take out nyaggie, because, as I said to pola, I didn't quite read the rules on the vigilante role as well as I should have, particularly the part about it not being smart to kill the first night. So, that's my fault, but Arfy claiming to be vigilante seems very suspicious to me. And we can't forget that Arfy and Pola worked together very well last time around, which means that the trust factor is there between the two of them. I feel as though Arfy may be using that to his advantage knowing that, whatever he claimed to be, Pola would believe him. So there's my logic. Do with it what you will.

I vote to lynch Arfy.

Posted by polabonez on 8/24/2012 5:49:00 PM (view original):
I don't side with anyone... especially not arfy....  but your point is valid that because of last game I might be inclined to trust him more, which I could be wrong.

The fact is:  both of you claimed vig.  One is lying.

Page 5 of this thread caesari (at 7 PMish) said he was waiting on the vigilante to make his pick.  Arfy is known to not post much during the day and stir **** up at night, just like I am known to be drunk at night and stir **** up during the day. 

Right around that time of the day arfy started posting in grindi's thread, and at 7:40ish caesari "had the vig's pick"

Also....

Your sitemail telling me that you were the vigilante was very close to csudak's post only minutes later about "wondering if the vig would be scared to come out because of killing off the townsman"  and that was the exact same reason you mb625 told me he was worried about coming forth....

Just seems pretty fishy to me... on both accounts... like the story was forced.

I probably won't be around to hear arfy's rebuttal since its Friday night... but I'm going to stick with csudak as my vote....  Whatever the townsmen do, don't leave this in a tie.... Go high and dry for whoever you think but no ties allowed.

I'll check in from the bar and be able to give short answers.... but for the reasons above... I think the vote today is either md625 or csudak.

Here is why I think we vote csudak:

The cop and Sheriff need to come forth.. so they can work together on separate investigations....  and they should be able to come out and say it in the open if we vote off Csudak...

why?  Because if we don't kill of the vig, the mafia has no choice but to kill him off... (because the REAL vig is going to kill the fake vig tonight), so the cop and sheriff are safe no matter what... or else the Vig kills a mafia man.

If I am wrong about csudak.... same scenario we just are one townie down and then it has to be either babcick or myself....

The reason I didn't make a pick until that late was mainly because I just wasn't sure who to go with, and, as you all know, I was convinced that I should try to take someone out. Usually the only times I check WIS are on the cycle hours (1,4,7, etc...), well my Tuesday-Thursdays are kind of jammed with classes (I go from 9:30 AM until 2:00, then from 3:30-5 and on Thursdays I have a night class that goes from 5:30 until 7:30) so I decided to wait until I got from my night class to ponder who I should go after. The fact that Arfy posted in Grindi's thread at the same time is purely coincidental. 

Posted by polabonez on 8/24/2012 4:15:00 PM (view original):
I see right through you Casey.

On another note outside of Mafia...  I'm leaving out of the country on 9/11 and won't be back until Sept 30.  I plan on starting a Survivor right after.

I have been working on it for the past 3 days and with what I plan on doing for it probably will be working on it up until the time I leave.  I am more excited about this one than any... since from a host standpoint the crappy part of it is not being able to take part of the game inside of the game.... the only thing I have control over is the idols..

This time... they will (hopefully) be much more difficult and will take a lot of thought, and almost an Internet scavenger hunt so to speak to come up with the idol which I will have had 3 weeks worth of groundwork laid....

Should be fun, I think.

Posted by mb625 on 8/23/2012 8:55:00 PM (view original):

Posted by iamthetwo__2 on 8/23/2012 8:48:00 PM (view original):
Vigilante (the vigilante will be town sided, and can kill at night. He should be VERY CAREFUL, though, as if he and the mafia elect to kill the same person at night, he will die along with the mafia's target. He also should not kill the first night for strategic reasons).

Dumb Vigania ooops I mean vigilante.  He shoulda put more stratagizing into his move.  Now we are down to 2 townies if I understand the rules correctly. 

Yep... not looking so good for us so far. Kind of put us townies behind the eight-ball.

The reason I didn't make a pick until that late was mainly because I just wasn't sure who to go with, and, as you all know, I was convinced that I should try to take someone out. Usually the only times I check WIS are on the cycle hours (1,4,7, etc...), well my Tuesday-Thursdays are kind of jammed with classes (I go from 9:30 AM until 2:00, then from 3:30-5 and on Thursdays I have a night class that goes from 5:30 until 7:30) so I decided to wait until I got from my night class to ponder who I should go after. The fact that Arfy posted in Grindi's thread at the same time is purely coincidental.   MB making excuses and accusing Arfy.  So I figured we need to play catch up and I will just go ahead and come out and say it.  I am Vig.

I am pretty sure that would make mb mafia then for fake claiming it.  They will kill me tonight.  That's fine.  I will kill mb.  So that means we have to find the other mafia member.  Arfy accusing MB.  Who is telling the truth--------Only the shadow knows for sure.