orangepace -- I like that reverse WIS for league seeding. That'd make it pretty crazy for the first 5 years or so. I'll add that idea to the vote that'll come out!
genuvar, I would like bigger divisions, but I think it's more fun if you play everyone in your league. There will only be rare circumstances where you can't play everyone (27% of years where conference teams face each other). In that case, CC may decide it, or point differential. For the most part, we should be able to make it so everyone meets, especially if we get interest from all of the conferences (instead of being, say, OVC-heavy).
I like your idea for using head-to-head as a starting point (although it screws me over :) ). I will put that idea up to vote as well in the coming days.
hookemhorns--My bad, wish I would have thought of this sooner before a lot of people already scheduled non-conference for next year. We could potentially put you with conference teams that you know will play each other and still get you in. Save that last non-conf spot for now :)