AAA. He could be a bad 2B or a good LF or even a passable RF. However, he doesn't carry a COF bat. You could keep him around as a utility player but he shouldn't be a BL starter.
As an added comment, you shouldn't skimp on D at SS/CF. If you have to sacrifice a bat to do it, I always go that route. If either of them have double digit negative plays, do something else.