Howz bout this...
Neither one of them deserves to be in the hall.......BUT....
I'd put Ichiro in because of his lineage as a groundbreaker for Japanese players and the fact that, though he was a singles hitter in a corner OF spot, he was still an amazing hitter. Raines could steal a base or five, but was never even CLOSE to the overall player that Ichiro was, and is. Plus, if Dawson and Rice are in, I kinda think Ich deserves his spot, and by that criteria, so does Raines. But if it were up to me, the only one of those four that would get in would be Ichiro. Dawson and Rice didn't deserve to get in, neither does Raines, but Ichiro is a different story, plus he's still going and could easily play for another 3 to 5 years, thus padding his stats MUCH farther.