Biggest Pitcher Bargains Topic

I have doing some pretty extensive research on pitcher values in OLs and I am getting pretty close to being finished.  I thought that I'd share a sneak peak at my findings, so I present the 10 biggest values* in absolute salary dollars in the sim.


1908 Addie Joss, 342ip  $1.77
1909 Cy Morgan, 311ip  $1.73
1908 Ed Summers, 319ip  $1.30
1909 Cy Morgan, 243ip  $1.52
1907 Addie Joss, 361ip  $1.44
1909 Ed Summers, 301ip  $1.30
1906 Jack Pfiester, 268ip  $1.35
1905 Irv Young, 398ip  $1.32
1907 Tully Sparks, 293ip  $1.31
1918 Stan Covelski, 397ip  $1.29


*I am defining value as the difference between actual salary and expected salary based on performance or expected performance in OLs.  
12/8/2011 11:40 PM (edited)
Interesting.  At the risk of stating the obvious, the number of pitchers outside the 1900-1910 decade is exactly one.  Conspicuous by omission are Mordecai Brown`08, Ed Walsh `07, Bill Bernhard `02, Jack Taylor `02 and Doc White `06.  Especially Bernhard.   Do you have the right dollar figure for Ed Summers `08?  Surprised to see him listed ahead of Ed Summers `09 and not sure if that was what you intended.
12/8/2011 3:44 AM
I don't understand what the dollars mean. Does that mean that Joss should cost 1.77 times more than he does?
12/8/2011 8:57 AM
no just add 1.77 to his salary


"value as the difference between actual salary and expected salary base"
12/8/2011 9:06 AM
I guess we'll see this in the finished product, but how much of a difference does fielding normalisation make to these values? Just eyeballing the charts, it seems it should be affecting the 1900's AL pitchers a fair bit, though not so much the 1900's NL pitchers.
12/8/2011 3:12 PM
This post has a rating of , which is below the default threshold.
Posted by brianjw on 12/8/2011 3:12:00 PM (view original):
I guess we'll see this in the finished product, but how much of a difference does fielding normalisation make to these values? Just eyeballing the charts, it seems it should be affecting the 1900's AL pitchers a fair bit, though not so much the 1900's NL pitchers.
I did not consider how fielding affects run scoring [against].  My study was tsrictly era.
12/8/2011 11:29 PM
Posted by seels on 12/8/2011 10:59:00 PM (view original):

Nice list, but I'm not sure going purely by dollars is the best way to do it.  For example I bet there are $400K pitchers worth twice as much as they cost.

I looked at that too.

Year Last Name First name Team IP Salary Actual $/IP Expect $/IP Value/IP ($/IP) Value ($)
1988 Milacki Bob Baltimore Orioles 26.0 $1,231,122 $47,351 $59,311 $11,961 $310,976
1910 White Kirby Boston Doves 28.0 $474,927 $16,962 $27,157 $10,196 $285,479
1983 Heathcock Jeff Houston Astros 28.0 $1,045,024 $37,322 $47,466 $10,144 $284,020
1918 Toney Fred New York Giants 112.0 $4,203,375 $37,530 $47,489 $9,958 $1,115,341
1918 Northrop Jake Boston Braves 53.0 $2,234,464 $42,160 $52,115 $9,955 $527,637
1921 Shea Red New York Giants 34.0 $812,436 $23,895 $33,837 $9,942 $338,027
1915 McCabe Tim St. Louis Browns 44.0 $1,476,708 $33,562 $43,186 $9,624 $423,458
1942 Biscan Frank St. Louis Browns 29.0 $1,084,342 $37,391 $46,985 $9,594 $278,229
1915 Dumont George Washington Senators 43.0 $1,650,416 $38,382 $47,803 $9,421 $405,092
1910 Moyer Ed Washington Senators 27.0 $242,832 $8,994 $18,323 $9,329 $251,889
1915 George Lefty Cincinnati Reds 30.0 $441,636 $14,721 $23,980 $9,259 $277,767
12/8/2011 11:36 PM
This post has a rating of , which is below the default threshold.
I'm curious how you figured out what their expected salary (or expected $/IP to be exact)? 
12/9/2011 12:19 PM
Complex zubinistic math!
12/9/2011 12:28 PM
12/10/2011 2:09 PM
12/12/2011 3:41 AM
Posted by boogerlips on 12/12/2011 3:41:00 AM (view original):
Nice call Boog. 
12/12/2011 9:58 PM
Topped by request.
7/17/2013 12:20 AM
12 Next ▸
Biggest Pitcher Bargains Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2016 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.