Who would you start Topic

I'm going into 1992 in a progressive that allows 18 keepers and I have the following returning bats:

Pos Player B PA/162 AB/162 HR RBI SB-CS SO-BB AB/HR AVG OBP SLG F/R Salary
C 1992 Chris Hoiles R 371 310 20 40 0-2 60-55 15.5 0.274 0.384 0.506 A/B $2,590,860
2B 1992 Craig Biggio R 721 613 6 39 38-15 95-94 102.2 0.277 0.378 0.369 B/C- $5,073,971
3B 1992 Ken Caminiti S 557 506 13 62 8-6 68-44 38.9 0.294 0.350 0.441 A-/D $3,748,852
OF 1992 Tony Phillips S 733 606 10 64 5-3 93-114 60.6 0.276 0.387 0.388 D+/A- $5,089,018
OF 1992 Brett Butler L 676 553 3 39 41-21 67-95 184.3 0.309 0.413 0.391 A/C+ $6,029,933
OF 1992 Barry Bonds L 612 473 34 103 39-8 69-127 13.9 0.311 0.456 0.624 A-/C+ $8,209,560
OF 1992 Paul O'Neill L 584 496 14 66 6-3 85-77 35.4 0.246 0.346 0.373 A/D+ $3,432,583
OF 1992 Jay Buhner R 629 543 25 79 0-6 146-71 21.7 0.243 0.333 0.422 A/C- $3,919,806
1B 1992 Andres Galarraga R 347 325 10 39 3-3 69-11 32.5 0.243 0.282 0.391 C/B- $1,830,198
3B 1992 Dean Palmer R 613 541 26 72 8-6 154-62 20.8 0.229 0.311 0.420 C/D $3,188,143

I'm wondering who and where everybody would start guys.  To me it's pretty obvious that Galarraga and Palmer should sit; I could use Palmer at 1B, though, and playing home games in Wrigley he would undoubtedly pop some homers and drive in some runs from the bottom of the order.  Assume I draft guys to play SS who look something like 100 OBP+, 85 SLG+.  My natural lineup would probably be:

1) Phillips, RF
2) Butler, CF
3) Bonds, LF
4) Hoiles, C
5) Caminiti, 3B
6) Buhner, 1B
7) SS
8) P
9) Biggio, 2B

Against lefties I'd swap Biggio and TP.  Obviously I'll need a backup for Hoiles who likely bats 6th or 7th instead of cleanup when he's in.  The things I'm wondering about are:
1) should I substitute Paul O'Neill for Buhner against righties?  Or even for Biggio?  I can play Phillips at 2nd.
2) which outfielder would you put on first?  Or would you use Palmer there?
3) would it make more sense to put Biggio and TP 1 and 2 since they have tons of PAs?  I hate putting two guys with absolutely no power, not even doubles power, at the top of the order.  If I make the change it would be 3.  But I do think it makes sense to have them both in front of Bonds in one way or another, and with this group of guys it seems obvious to me that Butler should hit right in front of Bonds.  He'll be on base all the time, has the speed to score on a double, and obviously has the opportunity to score on home runs.
9/27/2012 8:16 PM (edited)
Also, since when can I post spreadsheets in Waterfox?  It's awesome, because my IE is on the fritz and keeps freezing up.
9/27/2012 8:15 PM
How many teams in the league?
9/27/2012 8:48 PM
16, but I don't see how that's relevant.  Unless maybe your weighting of OBP vs HR is significantly weighted based on how watered down the pitching is, I suppose.
9/27/2012 9:09 PM
it's relevant because none of those guys are good options.   You should be able to use your 5th and 6th round picks (or 6th and 7th) to pick a better 6 hole hitter.
9/27/2012 10:43 PM
At what position?  '92 isn't a good year for first baseman.  The most expensive guy available with a rating at 1B is Erik Karros, and only because he's a rookie; he'll probably be gone in the 2nd round.   The only .400 slugger likely to survive into the later rounds who can play 1B is Sid Bream, and I don't think that's much of an improvement over Buhner, at least not in my park.
9/27/2012 10:58 PM
To further expound on that point, '92 isn't a great hitting season at all.  Not sure what you're thinking, but everybody above Galarraga in my spreadsheet has OBP+ and SLG+ over 100 except Biggio, whose SLG+ is 100 even.
9/27/2012 11:03 PM
Can you piece together two 150 PA guys?

Phil Clark
Lance Blankenship
Warren Newsome
Geronomo Pena

All those guys are improvements I think...(I did it quickly)
9/27/2012 11:05 PM
Well I'm planning on drafting one more pitcher at some point, 2 SSs, a C, and then whatever 2 guys left at the end have the best OPS numbers.  Dunno who will be around at that point.
9/27/2012 11:09 PM
Well,  I am willing to bet your 6th and 7th round draft picks will be better than Buhner.

You probably don't need to take the 2nd SS early either.  With 16 teams, probably 12 of them all ready have SS for the year, the demand for SS will be low even with the short supply.
9/27/2012 11:16 PM
Who would you start Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2018 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.