A little late to the conversation, but I too would've picked a different category if I picked later in the draft on my first category. I picked it early when we had very few categories with starting pitching and thought having a category to complement the aces category would be nice so as to have both a stud and a lower quality starter would be nice, but in retrospect I would have picked a category with a larger gradient of talent and a smaller group of players.
I was thinking of this more along the lines of a Big Dick league where every category fills out a spot on the roster instead of looking at categories as something that could potentially fill any roster spot.