All Forums > Hardball Dynasty Baseball > Suggestions > Real-time FA bidding
5/16/2013 6:49 PM
You're 10 pages and 7 months too late.
5/16/2013 7:49 PM
Yeah, I didn't notice that part until after I was done writing all that.  
5/16/2013 8:07 PM
I liked the part where you referred to "marathon posts" and then did one.  

That was pretty awesome.
5/17/2013 2:12 AM
5/17/2013 4:38 AM
EBay bidding would be a disaster. Hate it.
5/17/2013 7:54 AM

You obviously don't understand how it would work.

1/16/2014 5:41 PM
Bump for fun!!!!
1/16/2014 7:25 PM
Anyone know why this idea didn't take off/
1/17/2014 12:05 PM
This was a great thread.  It should go into the "Forum Thread" Hall of Fame.

With the wrong position listed, of course.
6/26/2015 1:45 PM
Bump for cshakes.
6/26/2015 2:09 PM
I'll read this again sometime.

My test on how far down the stupid hole I could go here and people would go with.

I stand by the original suggestion.  It would fix one of the major holes in HBD.  FA bidding is very poorly done.

Signed FAs is more about having 24 hours a day that week to be on the site and knowing the weird ins and outs than about strategy.

It's designed to get max $$ for the pretend players.  Not about having the humans who play the game pay the fair market price.

Current system makes it easy for newbies, or even those who think they know what they're doing, to over pay for players. Which results in people dropping teams and leaving really bad contracts behind.

If you think worlds that won't fill because nobody wants to take on the crap teams is a good thing, you like the current FA system. If you think that's bad for HBD, you want the FA system to changed.

At some point, which should be pretty clear, I pulled a Mike in this thread.  Started arguing and attacking people for the sake of it.  Sorry about that.  I was fun while it lasted.  Haven't done it since.
6/26/2015 2:14 PM
Do you understand how RL FA works?     It's designed to get max $$ for players.    And it's actually more difficult because agents will lie and say "Well, another team is offering 10/167m to your 8/133m" when it's all bullshit.     We get a nice, straight answer.

Real-time bidding for FA was worse than the simmy team suggestion. 
6/26/2015 2:15 PM
And, as I said, EVERYONE said it was a terrible idea.    You just wouldn't let it go.   Which is what you always do. 
6/26/2015 2:55 PM
I remember this was an entertaining thread.  I'll have to go back and reread it.
6/26/2015 7:26 PM
Wow, that took a long time to get through. tufft and MikeT, I didn't realize you guys had such a long, complicated history haha.  As for the content...

tufft, you may be correct that FA is flawed... but eBay style bidding does not even resemble a solution, ESPECIALLY if the people here want something resembling Major League Baseball - which they do.

The FA system as it stands is not as broken as you seem to think that it is, however.  In the real world, it is not so unlike HBD - exchanging numbers with a free agent, waiting a few hours to hear back while he talks with other teams and considers other offers, and getting an update.  I don't need to know what my competitor is offering, nor do I care how much the pretend player makes.  I do, however, care that I am being true to my own evaluation of the player, and that I am not over paying based on that evaluation.  However, should the contract based on my evaluation become a bust, I have to live with that, and that is part of the game.

In real life, people are signed to bad contracts, and teams have to live with them.  Yes, it could be a downside to a new player that his team was stuck with bad contracts.  I have been playing for four seasons, and had my fair share when I inherited the team - but that increased the appeal to me.  "How can I turn this thing around with all of these obstacles to overcome?"  It increased the need for strategy as well.

You seem to think that most of us that don't want a major overhaul of the current system just empathize so much with these fake players.  I don't care what my player is paid (as long as it is not more than however I valued him).  However, your stance exists to be sympathetic to the owners.  It's like you just want the owners to get the best end of every deal.  On that note, you should realize that that is not realistic, either.  In today's MLB, more often than not, the player gets the better end of the deal.  It's the current state of the MLB.  You can thank Curt Flood for that.  But if you want a game that resembles the MLB, this is as realistic as you can find.  There's a strong sense of strategy needed as it stands currently.

I love Major League Baseball.  I have dreamed of being in a front office somewhere since I was a middle schooler, and as a result, I absolutely love this game.  The game that you have said that you want is not one that closely resembles Major League Baseball, but I do hope that one day you can find whatever game it is for which you're searching.
of 12
All Forums > Hardball Dynasty Baseball > Suggestions > Real-time FA bidding

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

Popular on WhatIfSports site: Baseball Simulation | College Basketball Game | College Football Game | Online Baseball Game | Hockey Simulation | NFL Picks | College Football Picks | Sports Games

© 1999-, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.