That team is way worse!
There are 2 different types of "Sim recruits". One type is the recruits recruited by SimAI for a SimAI coached team, those are decent/fair recruits. The other type are recruits signed for a human coached team who didn't sign all their recruits.....and those recruits are awful!!!
Plus, a SimAI team has their practice times set up, an abandoned human team loses points every season if they never set up their practice plan.