I hate these kinds of threads, but I feel like I need to ask.
I am in a unique draft league where we all draft players in different categories. I have the first pick in one of the drafts and I'm trying to choose between 1914 Benny Kauff, 1920 Joe Jackson, and 2012 Mike Trout. Whoever I selected would be my leadoff hitter in a neutral park. Defense is nice, but not 100% important since I already drafted a B+/A outfielder and will have a chance to select an A/A+ outfielder.
All that being said, I have spent the last two days struggling to decide exactly who I should take. I see valid arguments for all three. So I turn to the interwebs for the answer. Tell me!