I used 1891 Jocko Milligan, whose ratings aren't the bottom of the barrel, but far from the top. This is my "3X the charm" team. He has played in 159 games, no + or - plays, 15 errors total, 12 throwing errors, 136 SBs, 47 CS, 21 passed balls. I don't think he hurt me, I have already clinched a weak division, but I don't think he helped, either. I could have done better for $5.3m. His batting didn't make up for his fielding.