MLB104432 - There's a great story of baseball lore (which some have said isn't true, but baseball fans never let the truth get in the way of a good story) where Rickey Henderson, after playing with John Olerud on the Mets in 1999, was reunited with him on the Mariners in 2000 after signing with the team halfway through the season. Supposedly, Henderson went up to Olerud during batting practice one day and asked him why he wore a batting helmet for BP, to which Olerud explained to him that he'd had an aneurysm earlier in his career. Henderson said, "There was a guy I played with on the Mets that wore a batting helmet for BP." Which forced Olerud to remind Rickey that they were teammates on the Mets.

Whether it's true or not, it's a great (and believable) story. There are many examples of players reuniting as teammates in their careers after spending time apart. And thus, another theme is born!

Here are the rules:

Select two players who were teammates in two different, non-consecutive seasons (1945-present) in their careers. Then draft a team of players who were teammates of those players in those two seasons - spun to any season in their careers. For example, Derek Lowe was teammates with Russell Martin from 2006-2008 on the Dodgers and then again with the Yankees in 2012 - you can make your team out of the '06 Dodgers and '12 Yankees, the '07 Dodgers and '12 Yankees or the '08 Dodgers and '12 Yankees. $120MM cap. DH AL only. No waiver wire. AAA - average. Name your team incorporating your teammates' names. Stadium must be one of the home stadiums from the two years you use.

Info that doesn't fit in the theme summary:
(1) No clones
(2) No trades 
(3) Your main players must be on your roster - again, twisted to any season in his career.
(4) The Rickey-Olerud connection above wouldn't work - despite the fact that they were apart for a few months, they played together in consecutive seasons. HOWEVER, some of the more astute geeks might point out that Rickey and Olerud also played together on the 1993 Blue Jays. So you could do '93 Jays and '99 Mets or '93 Jays and '00 Mariners.
(5) Any pair of teammates/seasons used will be unique to the league and any future seasons - for example, in the scenario above, if someone used Rickey-Olerud '93 Jays-'99 Mets, no one else would be able to use that relationship. And since Al Leiter was also a teammate in those years, no one can use Leiter-Henderson, Leiter-Olerud or any other combination that would use the '93 Jays and '99 Mets.
(6) You don't have to decide AL (DH) or NL (no DH) when you claim your team - but when you enter your team in the league, let the Commish (ssupfoo) know which league you want either in the forum or by sitemail. Only entering the league claims your spot in either league. If one league fills before the other, the only option will be what's left. First-come, first-served on AL vs. NL.

CLAIM YOUR PLAYERS IN THE FORUM! You must claim your player in the forum. If you enter a team that uses a player that someone has already claimed in the forum, your team will be put back into the draft center. NOTE: Claiming a player in the forum only entitles you to that player - it doesn't necessarily entitle you to a spot in the league - that's first-come, first-served. As the league gets close to filling, make sure you get your team in so you don't get shut out. 


1. ssupfoo - Jeff Juden/Casey Candaele, '91 Astros/'97 Indians
2. splitter24 - Rod Beck/Darren Lewis, '93 Giants/'01 Red Sox
3. dlchow - Jim Corsi/Mark Portugal, '91 Astros/'99 Red Sox
4. bluetufts - Ray Sadecki/Willie Mays, '66 Giants/'73 Mets
5. baines03 - Roger Clemens/Jose Vizcaino, '00 Yankees/'05 Astros
6. finn2030 - Bill Mueller/Nomar Garciaparra, '04 Red Sox/'06 Dodgers
7. q-tab - Steve Finley/Luis Gonzalez, '91 Astros/'03 Diamondbacks
8. kriz - Matt Williams/Mike Jackson, '92 Giants/'97 Indians
9. go_pre - Mike Lansing/Pedro Martinez, '94 Expos/'01 Red Sox
10. leganovci - Greg Colbrunn/Danny Bautista, '98 Braves/'00 Diamondbacks
11. willhinson2 - Pat Burrell/Aaron Rowand, '06 Phillies/'11 Giants
12. malinowt - Johnny Hopp/Johnny Sain, '46 Braves/'51 Yankees

1. splitter24 - George Foster/Ken Henderson, '69 Giants/'79 Reds
2. bsm7 - Reggie Jackson/Catfish Hunter, '74 A's/'77 Yankees
3. dodgebob - Manny Ramirez/Alan Embree, '96 Indians/'02 Red Sox
4. mick33 - Joe Morgan/Pete Rose, '77 Reds/'83 Phillies
5. redtrain - Kevin Brown/Ruben Sierra, '89 Rangers/'04 Yankees
6. ryan_horner - Greg Maddux/Andruw Jones, '96 Braves/'08 Dodgets
7. ETSTim - Carney Lansford/Dennis Eckersley, '81 Red Sox/'90 A's
8. specsman - Albert Pujols/Jason Isringhausen, '05 Cardinals/'12 Angels
9. leganovci - Hoyt Wilhelm/Tommy John, '67 White Sox/'72 Dodgers
10. gyrene - Steve Carlton/Joe Hoerner, '68 Cardinals/'75 Phillies
11. CarlosVal - Mike Piazza/Jose Offerman, '92 Dodgers/'05 Mets
12. jjper1 - Johnny Oates/Paul Blair, '70 Orioles/'80 Yankees

3/3/2013 9:13 PM (edited)
I'll get things started with John Tudor and Ricky Horton, who were teammates on the '85 Cardinals and reunited on the '88 Dodgers.
2/16/2013 6:33 PM
Alright - re-reading what I posted for rules, my Tudor/Horton team doesn't fit because they did play together in '87 and '88 (though Horton left for the White Sox for a half-season). Gotta have a commitment to the theme, so I'm going back to the drawing board.

Feel free to reserve players in the meantime.
2/16/2013 6:43 PM
Alright - I've adjusted my team. Going with Casey Candaele and Jeff Juden, 1991 Astros and 1997 Indians.

Come on in!
2/16/2013 10:29 PM
Can I use Jim Corsi/Mark Portugal, 1991 Astros and 1999 Red Sox?
2/16/2013 11:31 PM
2/16/2013 11:47 PM
Bill Mueller/Nomar Garciaparra - 2004 Red Sox & 2006 Dodgers.  NL
2/17/2013 12:53 AM
Manny Ramirez and Alan Embree - 96 Indians and 02 Red Sox
2/17/2013 7:34 AM
I'd like to give this a try with Catfish Hunter and Reggie Jackson, who played together on the 1974 World Series Champion Oakland A's and then were reunited on the 1977 World Series Champion New York Yankees.  Let's hope it is a winning combination for me, as well. I'd like to play in the AL.
2/17/2013 9:47 AM
Since I can't decide which team to go with, I'm going to use both:

George Foster and Ken Henderson (1969 Giants/1979 Reds) AL/DH

Rod Beck and Darren Lewis (1993 Giants/2001 Red Sox) NL/No DH

2/17/2013 10:03 AM
splitter - I like the 10-year reunion... I was looking for some players that have big splits to combine generations of talent on one team...
2/17/2013 12:32 PM
Edit -- Luis Gonzelez/Steve Finley.  Astros/D-Backs.  Years TBD -- I'll post with years later today.
2/17/2013 4:22 PM (edited)
another interesting league, ssupfoo.

i'll take Roger Clemens / Jose Vizcaino - 2000 Yankees, 2005 Astros

2/17/2013 4:14 PM (edited)
Ray Sadecki and Willie Mays - 1966 Giants and 1973 Mets - NL/No DH
2/17/2013 3:59 PM
OK, we're going with the 1991 Astros/ 2003 Diamondbacks (Luis Gonzalez/Steve Finley).
2/17/2013 4:39 PM
1234 Next ▸

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2018, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.