I would have Bautista in front of Jones. I'd have Jones batting 8th in an All-Star lineup. Aside from Hardy Jones has the worst OBP on the team, and it isn't particularly close... You always want to generally top-load your OBP to optimize your lineup, but it's particularly true for an All-Star lineup. When just about everyone is a threat to get XBH and do damage, a guy who doesn't get on base and strikes out too much is a black hole that kills innings. You don't stick a hole in the middle of your lineup.