I have to think the previous posters didn't spend much time studying the two players.
I used to play under the old engine and just started playing again with the new engine so not sure if this is still true, but based on my past experience I would go player A. The sum total of strength, GI, and Tech is higher. He will be a better player in the long run due to being more balanced. Player B also has very low WE, too low for me to ever take unless he will start as a freshman. Also remember that attributes that start especially high won't increase as much or as fast. Plus Player A has great speed and hands, which do matter. Player A is the complete package. Player B will fumble the ball on you.
Project what the attributes will be by the time each player will be a starter and you will have your answer. Seems like Player A will start his 4th year around a 65/50/60 QB with plus speed. Give me that all day and I can win with it. Redshirt him and you've got a great two year starter.
For me, low STR QBs have always been interception machines. Probably has alot to do with offensive style. If you only throw short passes then the low STR may be okay. Has always seemed to me that any one of the three attributes that is especially low creates a very high chance for INTs which will not be overcome by one of the three attributes being espcially high.
Basically give me a 40/40/40 qb recruit any time over a 20/60/40, especially if the first one has higher secondary attributes. And don't forget about potential, which you didn't mention...
Plus Player A has a mohawk...I mean come on, look at his pic...he is a bad mf'er.
7/25/2013 10:19 PM (edited)