zephyr1949: Different it is -- here you go:
1. OF Duke (Midget) Reilley 1909
2. box score 9/8/2009 Rays at Yankees (use any two players who appeared in the game)
3. OF Colby Rasmus 2009-12
4. SS Herman Long 1889-1904
5. 1989 Detroit Tigers batting orders (no pitchers since they were in the AL)
6. 1905 Pittsburgh Pirates roster
7. 1950 Cleveland Indians fielding (incl pitchers)
8. P Jesse Flores 1942-50
9. box score 9/18/2009 Giants at Dodgers
10. OF Tyler Colvin 2009-12
11. P Jeff Tabaka 1994-2001
12. Miami Marlins Hall of Fame Register
(lists two guys -- Andre Dawson 2005-06 and Tony Perez who managed the 2001 team. Use Dawson in one of his Marlins seasons, but for Perez, you can use either a season of his career or any player who played for him on the 2001 Marlins.)