Not sure what I'd do in this case - I'd have a talk with both owners involved. For future reference though, I'd just say that if you need a proxy pick made, like FRAZZMAN80 said, send it to the guy who picks after you - and also, the three or four that pick after him. That way, even if one or two of them aren't on-line at the time of your pick, everyone else after you will know that YOU want that particular player. You can never send a proxy pick to too many other owners - as long as they're scheduled to pick AFTER you are.