Anyway, what hasn't already been said? Your shining star is OPS+. I question any stat that says Rick Monday, Bernie Williams and Adam Dunn were equally productive. I question it even further when it says that Robin Yount and Dave Kingman had similar production. I've claimed, many times, that Martinez was far more adept at walking but not much else. I backed it up by showing that, per PA, Martinez had one more hit, six of them doubles, 2 of them homers but he hit three less triples. You don't like that.
So what "counter argument" is left?