Noah, while I appreciate your comment...let me assure you (and all the other guys above who have suggestions on a formation that they do not use), I have used every combination available and I have the talent to execute it. Thus far this season I have not thrown a single pass. My intent is NOT to outthink the SIM.....it is to TEST the WB vs the SIM.
I like to think that I've had a pretty good wishbone attack in the past, not only in Heisman, but also in a couple of other worlds under different IDs and as an offensive coordinator for a couple of other teams.
The issue is that the wishbone, as a formation, has been DECREASED in its effectiveness as a formation. At the moment, I'm down 6-0 at the half vs another SIM. I've gained a whopping 79....yep thats right 79 freaking yards while running wide EVERY PLAY. That is complete BS.
At the moment the engine does not appear to account for the other RBs blocking, or the WR blocking. Who knows how the offensive line really functions vs the def line and/or linebackers?
I'm truly on the verge of declaring the bone to be DEAD at the upper levels. I have done a non-scientific poll of coaches who have been using the Bone for a long time and all have the same opinion. If not dead, it is vastly underperforming.