I know you have a sh**load more titles than me, but for what it's worth, I'd roll with 04 Peyton and his 89 Pass Stamina. I've had a couple of 6 td games from 99 Warner in Open Leagues.
I got something like 40 tds and 2 (yes 2!) ints from 10 Brady in one open league.
In an OT loss back in the day, 75 Kenny Anderson tossed for 500+ yards. In another league, 75 Anderson directed that league's highest scoring offense (it helped that I was using 77 Walter Payton as my #1 back) to a #1 playoff seed. If memory serves, I lost that conference game in OT.
If all of my targted qbs had been taken in round 1 in NDL 4, I would've tried to replicate the Anderson/Super Elite back (i.e. Jim Brown, OJ, Walter, Adrian Peterson, Barry Sanders) formula.
I like sharing 'Sim Memories" like this. Anyway, like some guys prefer brunettes over blondes, everyone has their preferences.
BTW, the only time I used 04 Peyton in an open league, I won the Super Bowl.