Bubble Watch day 10:
I know I am a bit later than usually this season. But better late than never. Looks like the bubble is softish at the top but crowded where it counts this season. And if I have to bet, then no SIM will make the playoffs this season.
CIAA
It will be the same as every season in the final: NCCU vs Virginia State. But Elizabeth City is probably making this a three bid conference.
Locks:
NCCU (10-0, WIS: 1, SOS: 1) Could probably lose 4 more times. But other than Virginia State in the final, there is nothing remotely scary left.
Should be in:
Virginia State (8-2, WIS: 20 SOS: 44): Took a big step by pasting Elizabeth City today and basically has to keep serve against some SIMs, nothing difficult. A loss in the final would likely be no problem then.
Work left:
Elizabeth City (8-2, WIS: 32, SOS: 84): Well, whenever EC played a real opponent it wasn’t pretty. But it also held serve against the numerous easy SIMs on the schedule. If EC wins out, they will likely be on the bubble since the SOS is not going to improve, but tendency good side I’d say.
GLIAC:
Should be in:
Ferris State (9-1, WIS: 10, SOS: 41): Already pretty much wrapped up the west, and with the remaining schedule things would have to go very wrong for them not to make it.
Work left to do:
Grand Valley State (10-0, WIS: 17, SOS: 129): It was a bunch of cupcakes and a nice win over Delta State. While nothing super scary, the next three games are gonna be slightly tougher than the last 6. One loss would not be a problem, two would likely be ok, but three…
Saginaw Valley State (8-2, WIS: 31, SOS: 67): As far as SIMs go, this is a vicious one, having already beaten three coaches. That said, it also lost to the better teams on the schedule. With a game vs GVSU on day 13, and the traditional MOV problem of SIMs, I think it will take an upset for SVSU to make it in… but like I said, has already beaten 3 coaches this season.
GSC
The GSC has definitely become one of the more fun conferences.
Locks:
Valdosta State (10-0, WIS: 8, SOS: 81): The OOC was not super impressive, but Valdosta has not dropped the ball and so far also dominated in conference. The game vs UAM on day 13 looms large, but more due to conference implications than because of the playoffs. W Georgia did not make it into the watch due to its loss to a SIM today.
Should be in:
Arkansas-Monticello (9-1, WIS: 14, SOS: 85): Despite the loss to Delta today, it is hard to see UAM missing the playoffs completely. It would basically take losing every game left on the schedule
Work left to do:
Delta State (7-3, WIS: 26, SOS: 12): Won a squeaker vs UAM for the second season in a row. And Delta needed it too. After having lost to several good but not great teams they aren’t safe yet, but a fourth loss would have been devastating, and the rest of the schedule seems handlable. That said some SOS watching and slight sweating will remain.
Central Arkansas (7-3, WIS: 35, SOS: 39). Talk about a close call. UCA score 19 points in the fourth quarter to beat W. Alabama by one point on a touchdown that came in as time expired. Now UCA is in the drivers seat for the division crown. The playoffs are no certainty though. UCA currently sits on the bubble, with a few games left that can improve or kill its chances.
West Alabama (6-4, WIS: 22 SOS: 3)Lost to 3 top ten teams before today, no biggie; but this one today hurt. It came just as W. Alabama had the playoffs in its grasp. WAU has such strong SOS numbers currently, that they have decent odds of making the playoffs despite 4 losses. But even as good as the SOS is, a regular season loss vs W. Georgia or Harding would likely cut it extremely close. And if the SOS comes down a bit, things could get dicey even if they win out.
Need help:
Harding (6-4, WIS:44, SOS: 29): 4 losses requires a high SOS, and one may wonder whether the GSC north is quite good enough to supply the needed bump. In any case with two tough games left, the point is likely to become moot anyway.
LSC
Locks:
SE Oklahoma Durant (9-1, WIS: 6, SOS: 6): Lost to the WIS number one team, and is otherwise spotless against a pretty tough schedule.
Work left to do:
Abilene Christian (9-1, WIS: 27, SOS: 128): The big thing was beating TAMC yesterday, which will likely propel ACU to the championship game. That said, the SOS being fairly horrible this season, a loss in the championship would put ACU back on the bubble. Likely the good side, but there will be sweating and no hickups are allowed.
Texas A&M commerce (7-3, WIS: 24, SOS: 16): Is actually in a better position than ACU playoff wise. But cutting it as close to another loss like today is not wise, as a fourth loss would be dangerous despite the pretty nice SOS.
MIAA
A few seasons ago the MIAA was easily in the race for worst conference. Now the top may still not be super impressive, but the depth is definitely there. Despite that, the number of playoff teams might be low this season.
Should be in:
Work left to do:
Lock Haven (10-0, WIS: 21, SOS: 140): The best bet to make the playoffs among MIAA teams. The schedule so far was creampuff, undefeated is undefeated, and it would likely take two losses, before things get dicey.
Truman State (8-2, WIS: 33, SOS: 102): Lost the game to NMSU today, in the 4th quarter. Instead of putting Truman in good position for both the division and the playoffs, they are now square on the bubble. The MIAA north is more win heavy than in a long time, so winning out would likely suffice. But another loss anywhere along the road and all bets are off.
NW Missouri State (8-2, WIS: 36, SOS: 103): With the schedule being what it is, NMSU probably needed this win today to remain viable. The resume loss that really hurt is the one to UCW, and NMSU has no margin of error, even after todays win.
NCC
By its own standards, this is an up season for the NCC.
Locks:
Work to do:
South Dakota State (9-1, WIS: 19, SOS:132). Who have they played? Nobody. Who did they lose to: also Nobody. And the SOS numbers are just not aweful enough that a single loss would doom them.
Humboldt State (8-2, WIS: 25, SOS: 141): Who have they played (Ok, maybe Central Washington counts)? Nobody. Who did they lose to: also nobody. The SOS numbers are bad enough though, that a loss to anyone before the championship game would be problematic.
Need help:
Central Washington (7-3, WIS: 46, SOS: 71): Definitely needs to win out, and needs help on top of that. Likely would have needed the one today vs Humboldt. The win over NMSU was nice, but the loss to Augustana hurt.
NE-10
The west is a mess, with Stonehill and Pace having no team there that would qualify as a real quality win because teams lost too many OOC games.
Locks:
Should be in:
Long Island (10-0, WIS: 12, SOS: 95): Quite safe unless it starts losing to SIMs.
Work left to do:
Bryant (8-2, WIS: 29, SOS: 104): Some fairly decent wins on this resume, but nothing that is an autoqualifier. If Bryant loses to Long Island on day 13, there will be sweating, but it would likely be ok. Losing to anyone before that on the other hand, would cause serious problems.
Stonehill (6-4, WIS: 40, SOS: 40): There is no single loss on this resume that would disqualify Stonehill from being a respectable playoff team. But the overall number of them is concerning, as is the problem of lack of opponents that have the number of wins required. It might take winning the Conference to make the field.
Need help:
American International (7-3, WIS: 49, SOS: 87): If this SIM could beat Bryant on day 12, maybe theres a chance (Cue Jim Carrey)
NSIC
Teams like UM Duluth and WVSC were out and about, and won over and lost to a number of fringe playoff teams. But both would likely have to pull huge upsets and win the conference to make it in.
Locks:
Minnesota Crookston (10-0, WIS: 2, SOS: 17): UMC played 2 tough games vs Indiana and Northern and won them by 8/9 points, and beat the rest of its schedule to pulp.
Should be in:
Work left to do:
Northern State (8-2, WIS: 30, SOS: 88): The MOVs are good and the losses are both to top 5 teams. But the wins are not over impressive competition. Northern Sate likely needs to win out in division. A loss to UMC in the final might be sustainable, but it is not eniterly guaranteed.
Need help:
West Virginia State (7-3, WIS: 54, SOS: 105): Yes they lead the division, but even with an upset over Northern things WVSC would likely need to win the conference.
PSAC
The PSAC east remains the deepest division in Warner. The west on the other hand is currently a one team show.
Locks:
Millersville (9-1, WIS: 3, SOS: 1): Yes there are still tough games there, but the SOS is such, that nothing can happen.
Indiana (9-1, WIS: 7, SOS: 11): Has- for all intents and purposes, already won the west.
Should be in:
Mansfield (9-1, WIS: 9, SOS: 23): The one point loss to ESUP is a minor setback, creating just enough doubt to keep them from complete lock status but a SOS like this can easily sustain 3 losses and maybe even a fourth.
East Stroudsburg (9-1, WIS: 11, SOS: 34): The win over Mansfield really elevated ESUP. ESUPcan remove any doubts with a win over West Chester tomorrow. Should that happen they could play a division final vs Millersville on day 13.
Work left to do:
West Chester (9-1, WIS: 23, SOS: 116): 9-1 looks really good, but there are no easy games left. West Chester can likely affors one more loss, but a second one would put them on the bubble, and with ESUP, Kutztown and Mansfield still to come this could go any way imaginable.
Kutztown (7-3, WIS: 28, SOS: 26): Took a whoopin from Millersville today, the third loss in a row. Things are starting to get slightly bublish. It is uncertain whether a loss to Mansfield tomorrow would be sustainable, but another one to West Chester after that would certainly not be.
Need help:
California (4-6, WIS: 47, SOS: 13): Yes, the SOS is nice, but likely not nice enough to overcome 6 losses, particularly as it is not likely to improve anymore.
Edinboro (7-3, WIS: 45, SOS: 106): In theory still with some shot, in practice the game vs Indiana will end all hope.
RMAC
Any betting man would say that two teams will make it in.
Locks:
Western State (9-1, WIS: 5, SOS: 5): No dangerous oponents left and lots of margin.
Should be in:
Colorado Mines (8-2, WIS: 18, SOS: 28): The only losses are to SEO and Western, nothing to be ashamed of. Would likely have to lose to two SIMs to get into real trouble.
SAC
Locks
Should be in:
Carson-Newman (9-1, WIS: 15, SOS: 83): Tomorrows game vs Mars Hill is likely for the Division crown, but unlikely to pose a threat to CNs playoff hopes.
Work to do:
Glennville (8-2, WIS: 16, SOS: 27): Close to “should be in”, thanks to wins over UCWW and Mars Hill. But a win tomorrow over Lenoir-Rhyne would not only remove those doubts, but also put Glenville in line for a rematch with CN in the Championship game.
Lenoir-Rhyne (8-2, WIS: 37, SOS: 113): The losses are not horrible, but the wins are not impressive. Really need that game vs Glenville tomorrow
Mars Hill (7-3, WIS: 37, SOS: 113): Started slow vs a pretty decent SIM today but then ran away. Will need likely to beat CN tomorrow, in order to stay viable.
SIAC
Locks:
Quincy (10-0, WIS: 4, SOS: 24): Won this seasons rivalry vs Millersville, the only game that was really close
Should be in:
Kentucky State (8-2, WIS: 13, SOS:19): Lost the first two games to top 10 teams and has been flawless since. And there were several potential playoff teams on the schedule. It would take weird upsets to SIMs for things to go wrong.
Work left to do:
Lane (7-3, WIS: 34, SOS: 38): If the WIS playoffs were determined by a human playoff committee, then Lane would likely look fairly safe. The win over a decent Miles and particularly that win over Bryant would easily outweigh the three losses that were all to top ten teams (although hat was some epic beating Lane took from Quincy). Lanes predicament is that when WIS looks at Bryant it does not see the top 15 team I see, all it sees is a 2-loss team that is barely in the top 30, and more importantly it weighs the SIM part of the schedule equally heavy as the human part. And it just so happens that the SIMs that Lane played totally underperformed against other SIMs. As a consequence Lane is square on the bubble, and Sundays game vs St Josephs is an elimination game.
Miles (7-3, WIS: 38, SOS: 53): Plays Kentucky State tomorrow. Absolutely needs to take advantage of that chance to shine and win a game that would bump up its SOS, otherwise things will look really dire.
Needs help to get an at large:
St. Josephs (6-4, WIS:41, SOS: 25): There is a decent win over Truman, but the loss to Miles still hurts, but not nearly as much as the one today vs a middling SIM. There is still an outside chance that if it wins out, St. Josephs might make it into the field. But the necessitates that it overcomes its offensive struggles and beats Lane on Sunday.
Albany State (6-4, WIS:42, SOS: 18): Well, the tough games are over for this SIM, but that also means it needs to make a jump, without having oponents that help the SOS much.