Posted by retiredfart on 12/5/2015 5:59:00 PM (view original):
Trying a thread in the Theme League Classifieds.
Maybe we'll get a nibble.
I saw your thread and you can consider this to be my nibble. I have been in many progressives and this like nothing I have ever been in before. I have only used the LIVE DRAFT once several years ago. Before I swallow the hook I have some observations and a few questions. Please correct me if my observations are incorrect and excuse me if I ask any dumb questions.
Observation 1) Nothing really progresses. If you start with 1971 Phillies you don't advance to the 1972 Phillies You start every season with the same roster including the draft picks from previous seasons and any players you have twisted.
Observation 2) The team you start with is crucial to any success in future seasons. Since you will be potentially twisting up to 16 players, you better make sure there are 16 players worth twisting. Some teams have a lot of players that only have worthless seasons to choose from.
Observation 3) Once I commit to something I don't bail. If it says seven seasons. I am there for seven seasons. My only bad experiences with progressives is when one or more owners bail out. Then it takes weeks and weeks to find a new owner. Many progressives just fold because no one wants to wait for a new owner to show up.
Question 1) The team I am considering has way more than 25 draftable players on their roster. ( 19 players and 18 pitchers). Can I choose any 24 players that I want or do have to go with what the LIVE DRAFT gives me?
Question 2) It says the AAA players are used to fill holes in your line up. Does that mean they are only for teams with less than 24 players on there original roster? Since they are way above average, what's to stop you from sending half your team to the minors and playing mostly rookies? If the AAA are assigned randomly that brings a large luck factor into play.
Question 3) Can you change the season for one of your drafted players or do you have use the same one every season? Say I have 1995 Greg Maddux and I want to change to 1994?
Question 4) I notice you show a chart of draft picks and twists. Season 6 shows 1 draft pick and 1 twist. Season 7 shows 3 draft picks and no twists. Can you explain that to me?
Put me down tentatively for the 1993 Oakland A's
12/6/2015 4:08 AM (edited)