Correct, it is Coleman!

Ivan Rodriguez
Carlton Fisk
Bob Boone
Gary Carter

Those are 1-4.

Ausmus 7th, Al Lopez 9th, Pierzynski 11th, Parrish then Ferrell at 13.

Bench is 16, Yogi 19th. Berra played OF occasionally...Cochrane is outside the top 35.
Piazza 21, Freehan 24, Posada 25.

Benito Santiago was #10. I didn't think he was anywhere near that high on the list.

One last shot Tony Pena?

Posted by lastinspace2 on 5/16/2016 7:21:00 PM (view original):
One last shot Tony Pena?

Pena checks in at #6...oh so close...

Did anyone guess Sundberg? He's #8.

Bengie Molina is tied with Matheny at #55. Yadi, at age 33 has moved to 35th. He would need 400+ games to crack the top 10.

I had to look it up, a tip of the cap to anyone who gets #5

Posted by lastinspace2 on 5/16/2016 7:35:00 PM (view original):
I had to look it up, a tip of the cap to anyone who gets #5

Same, I can't believe I didn't get it. I'm a younger fan if that helps

When I saw the list, I know I wouldn't have gotten it. And I used to use the guy in open leagues...

I would have guessed Terry Kennedy or Ted Simmons ahead of him.

Rick Dempsey is at #20? Even that is shocking. He played that long? From '69 to '92? Even Courtney Love would have to admit that's a long time to be on your knees...

Since we are looking at catchers, #32 on the list is Rollie Hemsley (I have him on a Progressive Team). Rollie was a hard drinker, his drinking was so bad the team paid to have his wife go on road trips to try and slow him down. What finally slowed Rollie down was his young daughter, she later became Miss Missouri. In 1940 he caught a no-hitter by Bob Feller and revealed his association with AA. He broke the group's anonymity protocol, and was the first to do so on a national level. The rest is history.

How about Wally Schang?

Posted by gbakker on 5/16/2016 10:42:00 PM (view original):
How about Wally Schang?

38th

Posted by lastinspace2 on 5/16/2016 8:54:00 PM (view original):
Since we are looking at catchers, #32 on the list is Rollie Hemsley (I have him on a Progressive Team). Rollie was a hard drinker, his drinking was so bad the team paid to have his wife go on road trips to try and slow him down. What finally slowed Rollie down was his young daughter, she later became Miss Missouri. In 1940 he caught a no-hitter by Bob Feller and revealed his association with AA. He broke the group's anonymity protocol, and was the first to do so on a national level. The rest is history.

I tried to look it up. Why was their a group anonymity protocol and why was it a big deal?

The AA was a small mutual aid started in 1935 in Akron Ohio by a Bill Wilson and a Dr. Bob Smith. When Rollie spilled the beans Mr. Wilson decided to go on a publicity tour and AA grew from there. Anonymity is one of the cornerstones of AA, no one would want their name attached to being an alchoholic.

Posted by DoctorKz on 5/16/2016 8:01:00 PM (view original):
When I saw the list, I know I wouldn't have gotten it. And I used to use the guy in open leagues...

I would have guessed Terry Kennedy or Ted Simmons ahead of him.

Rick Dempsey is at #20? Even that is shocking. He played that long? From '69 to '92? Even Courtney Love would have to admit that's a long time to be on your knees...

heh i loled