The Bad Starters Experiment Topic

Harry Lochhead (from Wikipedia)

Robert Henry "Harry" Lochhead (March 29, 1876 – August 22, 1909) was a Major League Baseball shortstop in 1899 and 1901. Lochhead was born and died in Stockton, California.

Cleveland Spiders (1899)
As a rookie, Lochhead was the starting shortstop for the 1899 Cleveland Spiders, widely regarded as the worst baseball team in history. The 1899 Spiders had a 20–134 record (.130 winning percentage), scoring 529 runs and allowing 1,252. Lochhead has the dubious distinction of sometimes being referred to as the worst regular player on the worst team in history. His .238 batting average was 43 points lower than the league average (.281) and among the lowest among all starters in the National League in 1899. His 81 errors was by far the highest on the Spiders, though his .909 fielding percentage was on par with other National League shortstops that year. He led the team in appearances, playing in 148 of the Spiders' 154 games.

Detroit Tigers (1900-1901)

In April 1900, the Detroit Tigers, then a minor league team in the Western League, purchased Lochhead from the St. Louis Cardinals. In an article published on January 13, 1900, Lochhead received praise in The Sporting News: "In the past few years the patrons of Recreation Park have much admired the quick, snappy, aggressive playing of [Harry] Lockhead (sic) at "short." The big fellow from Stockton, who so closely resembles Bill Lange, has certainly acquired a showy dash and finish as a result of this season's association with the stars of the major league." (The Sporting News, January 13, 1900)

After the Tigers became a major league team in 1901, Lochhead played only one more game for the team. In 4 at-bats, Lochhead had 2 hits, was hit by a pitch, and scored 2 runs for the Tigers, for a .500 batting average and .600 on-base percentage. Nevertheless, the Tigers sold Lochhead to the Philadelphia Athletics on April 29, 1901. Lochhead batted .088 in 9 games for the Athletics. He played his last major league game on May 15, 1901.

Death at 33 after being lost in the desert
Lochhead died at age 33 at his mother's home in Stockton, California, reportedly from a long-lasting liver complaint, a month after suffering overexposure when he was lost in the desert near Bakersfield, California.

So, Harry began his career with what is considered the "worst team" of the time, did amazingly well with the Tigers (Minor League at the time), finally ending on a low note with only 9 games with the Philadelphia Athletics. Nothing I've found indicates any involvement with the sport after that. Unfortunately, with his tragic death in 1909, we may never know what he could have accomplished. As a newcomer to baseball history I can only speculate that he could have done really well in the minor leagues.

EDIT: Harry Lochhead (1899) has no history of use in the system. This means I am the first to have him on a team. Not bad.

4/22/2016 8:41 PM (edited)
32-49 at halfway...2 teams in the NL worse than you...220 runs scored. $30.6m spent on offense...not abysmal...
4/22/2016 8:07 PM (edited)
The Fourth Nine Games
4/05
at Detroit Renaissance
3-4 loss
Yankees 03
3-4 loss
at Yankees 03
3-2 win

4/06
try to win it all
7-5 win
at try to win it all
1-4 loss
Dice Man Cometh
3-5 loss

4/07
Dice Man Cometh
0-5 loss
6-5 win
stl
5-1 win

Here my team earned 4 wins and 5 losses, putting my record at 11 wins to 25 losses.
4/22/2016 8:20 PM
Well, Doc, I wasn't planning on getting into the playoffs, sooooo... Also, considering I spent that measly 30.6 million on 19 players, I think I'm doing better than anyone might expect.

Anyway, here is a more recent player I am using.

Jason Kendall (from Wikipedia)

Jason Daniel Kendall (born June 26, 1974) is an American former professional baseball catcher who played in Major League Baseball from 1996 to 2010. He is the son of former catcher Fred Kendall, who played in the majors from 19691980.

Pittsburgh Pirates (1996–2004)[edit]

Kendall made his major league debut 1996. In his rookie year, he hit .300, made the National League All-Star Team, and was named NL rookie of the year by The Sporting News (he finished third in voting for the MLB Rookie of the Year award). He was also an All-Star in 1998 and 2000.

In 1999, he suffered a season-ending injury when he dislocated his ankle while running to first base in a July 4 game against Milwaukee after attempting to beat out a bunt.[1]

On May 19, 2000, Kendall became the first Pirate to hit for the cycle in Pittsburgh's Three Rivers Stadium and Kris Benson pitched a three-hitter in a 13–1 victory over the St. Louis Cardinals.[2]

On November 18, 2000, Kendall signed a six-year contract extension worth $60 million. The contract made him the second-highest-paid catcher at the time, behind Mike Piazza.[3]

In 2002 and 2005, he led the majors in at-bats per strikeout (18.1 in 2002, 15.4 in 2005).[4] He also led the major leagues in 2005 in times reached base on an error (15).[5]

From 2002 through 2004, Kendall led all major league catchers in games and innings behind the plate. He is the Pirates' all-time leader in games caught.[citation needed]

Oakland Athletics and Chicago Cubs (2005–2007)

After the 2004 season, the Pirates traded Kendall and cash to the Oakland Athletics for Mark Redman, Arthur Rhodes and cash.

During the 2005 season, Kendall struggled at the plate. His .321 slugging percentage was the worst (by 20 points) among all major league players who qualified for the batting title. His .271 batting average was the second-lowest of his career. In the field, he allowed 101 stolen bases, more than any other catcher in major league baseball. However, he did bat leadoff for Oakland, something that is very rare to see out of a baseball catcher.

The 2006 season marked Kendall's first post-season appearance, as the Athletics clinched the 2006 American League Western Division championship on September 26. He recorded his first playoff hit in the second game of the American League Division Series off Minnesota's Boof Bonser.

During a game against the Angels on May 2, 2006 Kendall was involved in another benches-clearing incident. John Lackey threw a pitch that started high and inside to Kendall, and then broke back towards the plate. Kendall stepped out of the batter's box and began yelling at Lackey, who told him to stop leaning over the plate with his elbow guard sticking out, trying to be hit by a pitch (as Kendall has been known to do throughout his career). Kendall then charged the mound and wrestled with the 6 ft 4 in (1.93 m) Lackey. The two spun around as catcher Jeff Mathis fell behind Kendall who was then punched in the ribs by Lackey, and the two tumbled to the ground.

On July 16, 2007, he was traded to the Chicago Cubs for fellow catcher Rob Bowen and minor league pitcher Jerry Blevins.[6] At the time of the trade, Kendall had the lowest on-base percentage (.261) and second lowest slugging percentage (.281) of any starter in major league baseball for 2007. In the field he allowed 111 stolen bases (131 attempts, 20 caught), more than any other catcher in major league baseball.

Milwaukee Brewers (2008–2009)

On November 21, 2007, Kendall agreed to a one-year deal with the Milwaukee Brewers.[7] Kendall threw out roughly 40% of base stealers in 2008. Upon making his 110th start of the 2008 season, Kendall fulfilled the option in his contract, securing himself a spot in the Brewers lineup in 2009.

On May 18, 2009, Kendall recorded his 2,000th career hit, becoming the eighth full-time catcher to reach that milestone.[8]

In 2009 he had the lowest slugging percentage of any starter in the major leagues, at .305.[9]

During his two years with the Brewers his AVG, OBP, and SLG were .244, .329, and .315.

Kansas City Royals (2010–2012)[edit]

On December 11, 2009, Kendall signed a two-year contract with the Kansas City Royals.[10]

Kendall underwent season-ending surgery on September 3, 2010, on his right shoulder after an MRI exam revealed extensive tearing in his rotator cuff.[11] He missed the entire 2011 season, because of this injury. He became a free agent after the 2011 season.

Kendall signed with Kansas City on July 19, 2012 to a minor league contract.[12] He played in two games for the AA Northwest Arkansas Naturals before announcing his retirement on July 24.[13]

He appeared on the ballot for the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum 2016 election and earned two votes.[14]

Playing style[edit]

Kendall was known as a fundamentally sound catcher who was very good at blocking pitches and handling pitching staffs, despite a relatively weak throwing arm. At the plate, Kendall was known for his very open batting stance and was a contact hitter who tended to "crowd" the plate. He was known to not use batting gloves. He was known as fiercely competitive, and was involved in several bench-clearing brawls. Kendall was also hit by pitches frequently as a result of his batting stance; he was hit 254 times, which is fifth all-time.

In addition to being a target for being hit by pitches, Kendall was also a stolen-base threat. His 189 stolen bases are second all-time in MLB history in the modern era to Roger Bresnahan for stolen bases by a player primarily playing catcher for his career. Kendall's plate discipline and rare speed at the catcher position also enabled him to be used as a leadoff hitter. Kendall started the game batting leadoff in 438 of his 2,085 games played, including 119 of his 147 games in 2004 and 90 of his 143 games in 2006 (leadoff is defined as starting the game as the first player to bat for his team and having at least two at-bats in the game). No other major-league catcher in the modern era of baseball has ever batted the majority of his team's games in the leadoff spot in any season[citation needed].

Book[edit]

Kendall has written a book with Lee Judge: Throwback: A Big-League Catcher Tells How the Game Is Really Played, released in May 2014 by St. Martin's Press.

Ironically, after reading about his play style, I noticed I have him second in my lineup for batting. Not bad for a guy with a performance history of 201.

4/22/2016 11:03 PM (edited)
The Fifth Nine Games

4/08
at stl
3-4 loss
The Dark Horses
2-8 loss
at The Dark Horses
3-8 loss

4/09
Geen Jacket Required
2-1 win
3-8 loss
7-2 win

4/10
Cincinnati Wallbangers
0-2 loss
6-4 win
2-3 loss

Here we have another 3 to 6 in the win/loss result, making for 14 wins to 31 losses.
4/22/2016 8:49 PM
The Sixth Nine Games

4/11
at American Shorthair
3-2 win
1-9 loss
1-6 loss

4/12
Two guys go up the hill
4-1 win
at Two guys go up the hill
11-4 win
at WHERE OH WHERE HAS MY UNDERDOG GONE
2-4 loss

4/13
WHERE OH WHERE HAS MY UNDERDOG GONE
2-7 loss
Seagulls
3-2 win
1-0 win

5 wins and 4 losses is better than I expected, but the season isn't over yet. This puts me and 19 wins to 35 losses.
4/22/2016 8:55 PM
The page died on me somehow. Third time.

The Seventh Nine Games

4/14
Seagulls
0-5 loss
at Simply Ravishing
7-1 win
12-4 loss

4/15
at Simply Ravishing
1-6 loss
at P+D+S=W??
7-5 win
11-4 win

4/16
at P+D+S=W??
2-3 loss
Detroit Renaissance
6-4 win
2-1 win

Another 5 wins to 4 losses. Not bad, really, considering my lack of team building skills.

Totals are now 24 wins and 39 losses.
4/22/2016 10:25 PM
The Eighth Nine Games

4/17
Detroit Renaissance
0-2 loss
at Jax Red Sox
7-4 win
Jax Red Sox
3-2 win

4/18
at Tampa Gunners
5-1 win
1-9 loss
1-0 win

4/19
Skeletons
3-2 win
0-5 loss
7-0 win

6 wins to 3 losses is a reverse of my expected win/loss ratio, so color me surprised on this one, guys.

Totals so far: 30 wins to 42 losses.
4/22/2016 10:30 PM
The Ninth Nine Games (because fourth time trying to get this post in is the charm, maybe)

4/20
AaTtHhLlEeTtIiCc OoAaKkLlAaNnDd
1-9 loss
1-3 loss
0-4 loss

at Dice Man Cometh
2-7 loss
2-4 loss
1-2 loss

at Geen Jacket Required
3-1 win
7-0 win
1-5 loss

That makes 2 wins and 7 losses, so my team is reverting back to expected form. That makes a total of 32 wins and 49 losses, so far, after 81 games.

That means we hit the All-Star break! Woohoo!

Surprisingly, one of my players, Brad Lidge, made the all-star roster. I've been using him as a closer, and he is currently ranked 3rd place for the Fireman Award. So far, I've been getting great use from him as a closer. His ERA is 1.02, WHIP 0.51, OAV .103 right now, though there are still 81 more games to go. We'll see.

Question: Does the all-star game get played in the sim or do we just get a simple roster?
4/22/2016 11:11 PM
No, the All-Star Game is not played.
4/23/2016 12:01 AM
Oog. Sorry for not posting lately. Just recovered from being sick.

4/23
at Cincinnati Wallbangers
0-7 loss
4-6 loss
0-2 loss

4/24
Luney Tunes
3-2 win
at Luney Tunes
6-2 win
at Comets
1-6 loss

4/25
Comets
2-1 win
at Malabar Falcons
0-5 loss
Malabar Falcons
1-4 loss

4/26
American Shorthair
3-2 win
1-2 loss
1-0 win

4/27
at Skeletons
3-4 loss
1-8 loss
0-3 loss

4/28
Tampa Gunners
4-3 win
0-4 loss
1-6 loss

4/29
at Seagulls
3-2 win
7-1 win
0-1 loss

4/30
at AaTtHhLlEeTtIiCc OoAaKkLlAaNnDd (Still feels like a brick wall)
3-5 loss
3-7 loss
3-4 loss

5/1
Dice Man Cometh
4-2 win
2-9 loss
3-4 loss

5/2
Geen Jacket Required
2-1 win
6-5 win
2-8 loss

That sits me at 43-68 so far.

Question: How many people mess with player rosters and manager settings after the season start?
5/2/2016 7:45 PM
I've felt a general malaise hit me while doing this, so I am sorry if anyone was still following this. Final results follow.

5/3
2-1 win
2-1 win
3-2 win

5/4
7-10 loss
2-3 loss
4-3 win

5/5
3-4 loss
2-5 loss
3-2 win

5/6
0-3 loss
3-4 loss
3-4 loss

5/7
7-4 win
2-3 loss
0-4 loss

5/8
4-8 loss
3-10 loss
0-13 loss (Dang, but unclejohn can make a good team)

5/9
3-6 loss
1-2 loss
3-4 loss

5/10
2-1 win
8-4 win
2-4 loss

5/11
2-1 win
0-4 loss
2-4 loss

5/12
5-8 loss
1-9 loss
0-7 loss

5/13
2-3 loss
2-8 loss
2-4 loss

5/14
2-0 win
1-3 loss
2-4 loss

5/15
1-6 loss
2-4 loss
3-1 win

5/16
3-2 win
5-1 win
4-5 loss

5/17
5-3 win
3-1 win
3-4 loss

5/18
1-0 win
1-2 loss
4-3 win

5/19
6-0 win
5-1 win
1-3 loss

Final Tally:
62 wins
100 losses

Better than the 54 wins I was expecting with a 1 to 2 win/loss ratio.

Home: 37-44
Away: 25-56

As for my one relief pitcher, Brad Lidge, not long after the all-star game, he dropped off the Fireman of the Year completely, reappeared briefly, then dropped off of it altogether. Sorry to say, he couldn't keep up the performance.
5/25/2016 8:07 PM
Batting Totals


Player
SN B G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI BB SO HBP SB CS AVG OBP SLG OPS STRK L STRK
Earl, Howard 1891 R 162 577 44 139 23 6 5 46 15 69 5 11 12 .241 .266 .328 .593 2 13
Kendall, Jason 2005 R 162 553 45 136 18 1 1 28 34 34 6 1 0 .246 .296 .288 .584 0 9
Casey, Doc 1903 S 162 529 29 136 8 1 0 40 21 33 4 12 10 .257 .290 .276 .566 4 11
Lochhead, Harry 1899 R 162 526 36 109 6 0 1 19 17 29 13 26 22 .207 .250 .224 .474 0 7
Griffith, Tommy 1924 L 162 499 45 132 11 6 2 43 28 25 2 0 0 .265 .305 .323 .628 0 12
Carr, Charlie 1904 R 162 490 25 101 11 0 1 29 21 22 1 3 2 .206 .240 .235 .474 4 7
Flynn, Doug 1978 R 162 463 22 111 7 5 0 38 24 39 1 1 0 .240 .279 .276 .555 0 9
Hassamaer, Bill 1895 R 162 458 41 102 15 2 1 41 26 26 3 2 2 .223 .268 .271 .539 0 8
Chesbro, Jack 1904 R 81 200 19 44 7 4 3 12 6 7 1 0 0 .220 .246 .340 .586 0 6
Young, Cy 1892 R 81 184 12 28 6 0 0 8 4 48 2 0 0 .152 .178 .185 .363 0 6
Dellucci, Dave 1999 L 133 123 18 35 4 2 2 10 13 26 3 0 0 .285 .367 .398 .765 0 4
Brown, Gates 1968 L 114 99 15 33 5 0 4 16 13 2 1 0 0 .333 .412 .505 .917 0 3
Ortiz, Hector 2000 R 120 98 10 33 6 0 0 6 8 9 2 0 0 .337 .398 .398 .796 0 3
Witek, Mickey 1941 R 103 96 7 26 4 0 0 6 6 3 0 0 0 .271 .314 .313 .626 0 3
Anderson, Dave 1990 R 111 91 8 29 2 1 1 10 4 21 0 0 0 .319 .347 .396 .743 2 3
Perkins, Broderick 1980 L 95 77 4 28 8 0 0 14 5 9 0 0 0 .364 .398 .468 .865 1 7
Archdeacon, Maurice 1923 L 112 71 23 20 6 0 0 11 5 5 0 0 1 .282 .329 .366 .695 0 2
Waner, Lloyd 1941 L 68 60 5 19 2 0 0 9 4 1 0 0 0 .317 .359 .350 .709 0 2
Wehner, John 1991 R 67 49 6 12 4 0 0 1 3 6 0 0 0 .245 .288 .327 .615 0 2
Betances, Dellin 2014 R 70 47 1 2 1 0 0 3 0 27 1 0 0 .043 .061 .064 .125 0 1
Zimmerman, Ryan 2005 R 49 47 4 17 3 1 0 4 4 10 1 0 0 .362 .423 .468 .891 0 4
Beck, Rod 1992 R 61 43 0 2 0 0 0 3 0 17 0 0 0 .047 .047 .047 .093 0 1
Burke, Tim 1987 R 67 34 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 11 0 0 0 .059 .059 .059 .118 1 1
Pafko, Andy 1943 R 31 27 6 8 2 0 0 4 0 7 0 0 0 .296 .296 .370 .667 0 4
Lidge, Brad 2004 R 70 21 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 6 0 0 0 .000 .045 .000 .045 0 0
TEAM TOTALS -- -- 2729 5462 426 1304 159 29 21 401 262 492 46 56 49 .239 .279 .290 .569 4 13
5/25/2016 8:07 PM
Pitching Totals
Player SN T G GS CG SHO W L SV SVO IP H R ER HR BB SO OAV OBP SLG WHIP ERA
Young, Cy 1892 R 81 81 1 0 19 43 0 0 527.7 543 253 211 10 178 201 .260 .317 .332 1.37 3.60
Chesbro, Jack 1904 R 81 81 0 0 20 36 0 0 507.7 508 231 199 3 146 194 .257 .310 .314 1.29 3.53
Betances, Dellin 2014 R 70 0 0 0 8 4 0 5 116.0 77 30 24 2 35 108 .184 .247 .243 .97 1.86
Burke, Tim 1987 R 67 0 0 0 6 3 2 4 103.3 95 34 30 9 17 66 .236 .267 .336 1.08 2.61
Beck, Rod 1992 R 61 0 0 0 2 1 1 1 97.7 80 40 33 4 23 59 .219 .270 .282 1.05 3.04
Lidge, Brad 2004 R 70 0 0 0 7 13 34 40 83.0 53 28 28 7 33 85 .180 .270 .295 1.04 3.04
TEAM TOTALS -- -- 430 162 1 0 62 100 37 50 1,435.3 1356 616 525 35 432 713 .244 .300 .314 1.25 3.29
5/25/2016 8:09 PM
Going through Performance History of the players I picked for the team:
I now have made the new Worst season for 1978 Doug Flynn. Stats match with his new worst. ......don't know how to feel about that.
.....aaaaand worst season recorded for 1904 Charlie Carr. And 1941 Mickey Witek..... *expletive not added* Now I'm morbidly curious.
*keeps looking*
Worst for 1923 Maurice Archdeacon..... That makes four players I now have a record worst for.
By all rights, my 1991 John Wehner should be the new worst, but I think the stellar fielding he did is preventing the system from using it.
Not the mark I was wanting to make on the game, but I will take what I can get.

On the other hand, 1924 Tommy Griffith has better batting stats than the PH best, but worse fielding stats. I feel like his best should appear on the PH, but I don't work for WhatIf.

Is there any correlation between getting bad stats in one and good stats in the other preventing the season from showing up as best/worst?
5/25/2016 8:33 PM
◂ Prev 12
The Bad Starters Experiment Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2024 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.