i've been in the a10 in phelan, or maybe knight, for the last 10 seasons. i was curious, because we've been about half full, or slightly less, this entire time. i don't think we've ever topped 6 coaches but we always have at least 4-5 - so by this logic, i should be seeing more than half sim CT victories, right? anyway, the sims have won 0 of those 10 CTs. thats a pretty terrible run, if indeed they are given some built in advantage (they aren't).
to me, there is nothing here - but my message to anyone who thinks there is, is, the issue is almost certainly on your end. not trying to be a dick, but really, look to your own teams. why are you losing to sims? they play in a very consistent way, they are easy to game plan against, they recruit poorly... really, seeing a sim opponent in the CT should result in a sigh of relief, or jubilation, or something along those lines.
most sims merit a defensive setting of +1/2/3, something in there, is that what you guys all played against the victor? occasionally, a sim can be nasty if a human leaves behind a particularly dangerous team, but i've never seen that last more than a season or two.