Unfortunately, I could only go up to 10/10 scouting, but here they are:

I'm leaning toward the 1st guy. Even if he drops 10-15 points in every category, he's still great. And I'm guessing the RP is more like 70/35 dur/stam. That CF's offensive numbers are pretty astounding, though.

18 y/o pitcher

Event	Season	HT	WT							dur	hea
Projected	-	6-4	216	94	9	14	58	13	7	38	78	56	91	52	70

Batting & Pitching Ratings

Event	Season									st	con	vsL	vsR	GB	Vel	#1	#1
Projected	-	10	14	39	39	37	13	80	79	96	91	91	99	49	76	73	78	63	45	61

21 y/o pitcher

Event	Season	HT	WT							dur	heal
Projected	-	6-2	189	93	42	17	27	56	17	85	76	40	83	30	100

Batting & Pitching Ratings

Event	Season									st	con	vsL	vsR	GB	Vel	#1	#2
Projected	-	13	14	39	33	38	1	78	79	47	93	100	100	53	31	65	98	44	0	0

18 y/o L/L CF

Event	Season	HT	WT	ovr	range	glove	AA	AS		DUR	Heal		Spd
Projected	-	5-11	200	92	89	71	72	78	10	78	100	83	88	32	68

Batting & Pitching Ratings

Event	Season	con	pow	vsL	vsR	Eye	B/R
Projected	-	73	97	76	100	94	33	44	59	21	0	29	4	2	43	93	0	0	0	0

At 10/10 it's a crapshoot. The format is crap but, if the 21 y/o P is P1-3 68/98/44, shitcan that guy. Those are so far off you have no idea.

The other two look reasonable, or more appropriately, consistent.

I see what you're saying. I was hoping 10/10 wasn't going to be such a crapshoot. I guess at these scouting levels, looking for "consistent" projections is pretty key in ranking players

I also think his DUR/STM is 78/47. Probably way off also. But, yeah, look for the "oddball" projections and remove players with them. I mentioned in another thread that a pitcher with splits of 37/88 is likely way off. You get the occasional hitter like that but not pitchers. One is off. Same with your pitches. 68/98 ain't happening. You might get a 78/82 but P2 isn't going to be 30 pts better than P1.

Thanks for the tips