mildnhazy,
I went with Koufax, Sutton, Tiant and Arrieta, and they are getting pounded as well. My pitching stats and yours are remarkably similar. My apologies if the comparison with me upsets you.
W L IP H R ER HR BB SO OAV OBP SLG WHIP ERA
Me 30 35 588.1 598 375 361 109 303 610 .258 .348 .439 1.55 5.52
You 32 33 587.2 645 377 362 110 238 620 .274 .345 .462 1.50 5.54
I think we both went wrong with our stadium choice: Briggs for you, Tiger Stadium for me (different name, same place). Compare our pitching with waitnsee, who chose similar pitchers but went with Dodger Stadium as his park. He is having more success in this theme than us. Guess that's why he's the champ.