Division II. Pick the DB you would prefer.

Player One, 'room to grow' potential:
48 ATH 58 SPD 49 WE 41 STA 47 STR 48 TKL 50 HND 47 GI 54 ELU 58 TEQ

Player Two, unknown potential:
45 ATH 55 SPD 40 WE 54 STA 38 STR 61 TKL 58 HND 52 GI 65 ELU 49 TEQ

I like player 1

Player 1. 3 potential vs unknown potential.

Find Player Two's potential and the question is answerable.

Posted by gt_deuce on 8/9/2016 3:09:00 PM (view original):
Find Player Two's potential and the question is answerable.

yes

Posted by spcbuzzard on 8/9/2016 1:25:00 PM (view original):
Player 1. 3 potential vs unknown potential.

yes

Can't waste $600 on a scouting report when a CV is only $1,300. If I had extra money, sure, but I never know if I will or not. Fights are never predictable.

Can always look at Formation IQ and GPA to help seal the deal as well. Going off what you provided, I like Player 1.

Role ratings not mentioned by the way?

Regardless of the money situation, player 2 DB with 40 WE (somewhat low) without above average potential would definitely tilt the decision towards player one, 49 WE and above average potential. Huge gamble to ignore the potential of player 2 because of budget, in my opinion, not a waste when it is critical to the decision making. Also, if you are already low on money why the worry about a battle that you probably can not win.

I am not a fan of ignoring potential, that is a crap shoot that will go the wrong way too often. Yes, you could cut the guy later if you guess wrong but in doing so you may potentially tip your roster balance to an unfavorable position.

It has been a long time since we were in Bryant together, GL with your decision Columbusbuck!

Player 1