A little late - still very hard to reconcile in both divisions, because so many teams ended up in these "mini-conferences" where Team A beat Team B, but Team B beat Team C and Team C beat Team A, etc. Anyway, here is what I came up with!
DIA (Key Wins in parentheses)
10. Miami (Virginia Tech, Virginia, Boston College)
9. Middle Tennessee (Navy)
8. Tennessee (Syracuse, Alabama, Florida)
7. Washington (Stanford)
6. USC (Florida, Tennessee, Nebraska)
5. Stanford (USC, Washington)
4. Ohio State (Boston College, Penn State)
3. Penn State (Notre Dame, Alabama, Northern Illinois)
2. Notre Dame (Stanford, LSU, Miami, Ohio State)
1. Texas (Notre Dame, Louisville, Texas A&M, Nebraska, Washington)
DIAA
10. Howard (Duquesne)
9. Southeast Missouri (Northeastern, Appalachian State, Jacksonville State)
8. Eastern Illinois (Howard, Southeast Missouri)
7. Liberty (Texas Southern, Southeast Missouri)
6. Duquesne (Howard, Texas Southern, Norfolk State)
5. Eastern Kentucky (Jacksonville State, Southeast Missouri)
4. Youngstown State (Liberty, Maine)
3. Sacred Heart (Tennessee Tech)
2. Drake (Sacred Heart, Eastern Illinois, Dayton)
1. Tennessee Tech (Drake, Southeast Missouri, Eastern Kentucky, Eastern Illinois)