Quote: Originally Posted By skonley on 3/22/2010
Using your Mattingly example, I just looked up Tony Gwynn. No frickin' way anyone on this site thinks Gwynn was a power hitter right? Well in 1994 (I know, I know.... strike shortened season) had a .568 slugging% with only 12 HR's.
So, you're point is despite the SLG% of Mauer that Mauer is not a power hitter?
Rasheed claims "Ball don't lie", and skonley, numbers don't lie.
I'd say yes, in 1994 Tony Gwynn hit for quite a bit of power considering his .568 slg%.
It's all in your definition of "power" hitter.
Perhaps you should have gone with a different adjective, like "HOME RUN HITTER".