Savage X Rosters/Commentary Topic

Last official eval post, eval'ing myself (sounds dirty) I got the champ right!

Pbandj:
Projection: 12-15
Actual: 17
Eval Grade: B+
Chewy:
Projection: top 10
Actual: 2
Eval Grade: C
Ty84moss:
Projection: In the 20’s
Actual: 12
Eval Grade: F, one a championship and pants’d me in the Finals!
Jpevans31
Projection: 8 – 12
Actual: 21
Eval Grade: D-
Mr. Savage DH555
Projection: 10 – 15
Actual 19
Eval Grade: C
Rob
Projection: 1st
Actual: 1st
Eval Grade: 1st
Gerryred
Projection: 5 – 10
Actual: 11
Eval Grade: B-
Jethroeg
Projection: 20’s
Actual: 22
Eval Grade: B+
Midge:
Projection: 5-10
Actual: 13
Eval Grade: C
Albiband0
Projection: 15-20
Actual: 23
Eval Grade: C
Jhsukow
Projection: 5ish, no worse than 10
Actual: 20
Eval Grade: D
24kpyrite
Projection: 5-10
Actual: 5
Eval Grade: B
dBKC
Projection: top 5
Actual: 9
Eval Grade: C+
Benhoidal
Draft Grade: A+
Projection: a close 2nd
Actual: 8 or 6
Eval Grade: B-
Raggedclaws
Projection: 5-10
Actual: 7 or 8
Eval Grade: A
Beloud:
Projection: 3rd
Actual: 10
Eval Grade: D
Jkaye24
Projection: 15-20
Actual: 5
Eval Grade: What’s below and F? W/D DQ?
Jcred5
Projection: 5-10
Actual: 4
Eval Grade: B+
Berkelon
Projection: 10-15
Actual: 24
Eval Grade: F
edsortails
Projection: 15-20
Actual: 14
Eval Grade: B
Ashamael
Projection: 5-10
Actual: 3
Eval Grade: C+
Amerk:
Projection: 10-15
Actual: 15
Eval Grade: B+
Steelers821
Projection: 15-20
Actual: 16
Eval Grade: A
20ks
Projection: 15-20
Actual: 18
Eval Grade: A
4/13/2023 4:55 PM
I think there is no doubt about this... Jcred is the GOAT of doing and keeping up with his evals, at least in Savage!! Incredible job, man.
4/13/2023 5:04 PM
Posted by ashamael on 4/13/2023 5:04:00 PM (view original):
I think there is no doubt about this... Jcred is the GOAT of doing and keeping up with his evals, at least in Savage!! Incredible job, man.
jcred has done a wonderful job. But c’mon man.
4/13/2023 5:52 PM
congrats robusk...undisputed Savage King

sorry chewy...not my best effort
4/13/2023 6:51 PM
new seasons are out...playoffs are starting...perfect time for a savage draft

not sure what to do with the all-d bumps...anyone know when it was updated last season?

ill get the new forum set up early next week and we'll go from there



4/13/2023 6:56 PM
Posted by dh555 on 4/13/2023 6:56:00 PM (view original):
new seasons are out...playoffs are starting...perfect time for a savage draft

not sure what to do with the all-d bumps...anyone know when it was updated last season?

ill get the new forum set up early next week and we'll go from there



Last season they announced May 20th and I think they updated in WiS around May 23rd.
4/13/2023 7:04 PM
Last year they didn’t announce the all defense teams until May 20th. That seems like a long time to wait so they can adjust fewer than 10 players.
4/13/2023 7:08 PM
If we assume a week to fill, two weeks to draft, two weeks to fill the league (all about standard) then we are probably starting right as the new defensive ratings post.

But that does add some intrigue as people are drafting with some guesses in mind. Seems like the teams are like 80% set though. I can’t imagine it having too much of an impact.
4/13/2023 7:17 PM
In the end it’s 10 players some of which might already have an 80-10 d rating and I think it’s sage to guess a couple of them. It’s not a salary cap league either so it won’t **** that up.
4/13/2023 7:30 PM
Posted by steelers821 on 4/13/2023 7:30:00 PM (view original):
In the end it’s 10 players some of which might already have an 80-10 d rating and I think it’s sage to guess a couple of them. It’s not a salary cap league either so it won’t **** that up.
Right. There are roughly like 12-13 candidates for 10 spots and most are more certain than others. We have already probably spent too much ink on it in comparison to the whole player pool. I mean the likely DPOY is already 100.
4/14/2023 7:11 AM (edited)
I don't really care about all-defense one way or the other, but I'm regrettably out if the draft starts before April 23rd. I'm not trying to do this **** on a cell phone on hotel wifi during my vacation. Obviously don't wait if you've got 24 other dudes ready before then.

(sending this to dh in case he doesn't read here)
4/13/2023 9:13 PM
Savage X is in the books!!!!
4/14/2023 1:58 PM
Coach Regular Season Wins Five Playoff Team Bonus First Round Bye Bonus Sum of Playoff Points Sum of Titles Score
robusk 232 20 0 88 40 380
chewy3344 257 20 16 48 0 341
ashamael 217 0 0 66 20 303
jcred5 235 0 8 56 0 299
jkaye24 218 0 16 36 20 290
24kpyrite 232 0 8 32 0 272
raggedclaws 242 0 16 10 0 268
benhoidal 224 0 16 24 0 264
dBKC 221 0 16 20 0 257
beloud 218 0 8 20 0 246
gerryred 217 0 8 20 0 245
ty84moss 188 0 0 32 20 240
Midge 210 0 8 20 0 238
edsortails 202 0 8 18 0 228
amerk1180 196 0 0 28 0 224
steelers821 200 0 0 16 0 216
PBandJ 191 0 8 14 0 213
20ks 189 0 0 24 0 213
dh555 188 0 8 16 0 212
jhsukow 172 0 8 12 0 192
jpevans31 180 0 8 4 0 192
jethroeg 169 0 0 0 0 169
albiband0 165 0 0 0 0 165
berkelon 157 0 0 0 0 157
4/14/2023 1:58 PM
I don't have a good way of keeping track of things, but I have to imagine that is the only time anyone has won 9 series where they were underdog/the road team.
4/14/2023 1:59 PM
Despite the win, some things clearly went wrong and some things went right.

What went right? The strategy of building positionless defensive terrors around Giannis... Kirilenko, Butler, Marion, Giannis, Plumlee, O'Quinn were all a perfect marriage together. I was always able to craft really awesome rotations. On top of that, Stoudemire fell to the 6th and could not have been a more perfect backup for Giannis since I had the rebounding and assists covered.

What went wrong? I rushed / didn't strategize enough at guard. Iguodala, Hill and T Brandon were awful fits on this team and I spent all season working around them / dragging them along. I hated having them. Also I really ended up not needing as much Gortat as I thought and I ended up sitting him a lot of the playoffs.
4/14/2023 3:11 PM
◂ Prev 1...29|30|31|32 Next ▸
Savage X Rosters/Commentary Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2024 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.