We have 7 LF and 2 RF so I combined them for the top 2 Corner Outfielders: 9 eligible, vote for 5.

Name	MVP	GG	SS	AS	WSR	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	SB	AVG	OPS
Nick Abbott	2	2	0	7	1	1848	2734	553	76	332	1338	636	.325	.947
Chi-Chi Costilla	1	3	2	9	1	1476	2707	580	84	393	1600	253	.316	.921
Flash Gibbons	0	2	3	8	2	1804	2765	624	99	390	1458	630	.287	.851
Andy Laroche	0	1	6	7	0	1914	3229	659	152	454	1738	376	.286	.851
Kevin May	0	0	9	8	0	1468	2614	474	39	388	1360	3	.317	.932
Anthony O'Day	2	0	7	7	1	1510	2494	359	59	698	1742	147	.298	.965
Placido Pelaez	7	0	11	11	2	2047	3184	492	132	836	2399	272	.322	1.035
RJ Santana	5	0	10	7	0	2022	2881	432	112	735	2062	717	.273	.897
Will Stevenson	3	0	11	11	2	1842	2740	370	35	684	1771	45	.293	.953

COF Votes
1. Pelaez
2. Santana
3. Abbott
4. Laroche
5. Stevenson

My COF Votes:
1. Pelaez
2. Abbott
3. Santana
4. Stevenson
5. Costilla

My COF votes: 1. Placido Pelaez
2. RJ Santana
3. Will Stevenson
4. Nick Abbott
5. Costilla

1. Pelaez
2. O'Day
3. Santana
4. Stevenson
5. Abbott

ELIGIBLE POSITION PLAYERS:

Name	HoF Year	Pos	MVP	GG	SS	AS	WSR	H	HR	RBI	BB	SB	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	SB	Fld%
Marcus Shipley	???	2B	0	1	4	4	2	2562	454	1502	925	208	0.278	0.346	0.489	0.835	0	0.976
Aroldis Torres	???	1B	0	0	1	0	1	2771	398	1419	922	27	0.309	0.375	0.498	0.873	0	0.998
Darren Harvey	???Final year	C	0	0	1	3	1	1639	421	1169	924	12	0.290	0.393	0.550	0.943	927	0.995
Gabriel McKain	2nd Year	LF	0	4	0	1	1	2423	9	547	731	1002	0.281	0.339	0.309	0.648	0	0.985
Clay Brinkley	2nd Year	DH	0	0	0	0	0	1197	230	692	702	3	0.288	0.395	0.496	0.891	0	-
Frank Mills	???	1B	1	2	1	1	0	1916	519	1342	603	16	0.268	0.328	0.521	0.849	0	0.999
Ivan Franco	???	2B	0	0	3	2	1	2419	338	1196	735	334	0.267	0.331	0.448	0.779	0	0.981
John Servais	2nd Year	2B	0	0	3	3	1	2468	327	1316	772	203	0.3	0.37	0.491	0.861	0	0.981
Mark Moore	????	2B	0	2	3	5	0	2556	388	1219	873	486	0.272	0.347	0.467	0.814	0	0.984
Oswaldo Martinez	????	SS	0	1	1	3	0	2365	129	828	685	317	0.271	0.327	0.348	0.675	0	0.98
Reynaldo Soriano	2nd Year	3B	0	0	5	5	0	2742	545	1523	976	180	0.278	0.347	0.49	0.837	0	0.977
Pete Pryor	1st Year	CF	0	4	1	8	2	2278	311	1140	683	293	0.279	0.339	0.473	0.812	0	0.992

ELIGIBLE PITCHERS:

Name	HoF Year	CY	AS	FoY	GG	WSR	W	L	SV	WHIP	ERA
Willis Tanner	4th year	0	6	3	0	0	68	91	485	1.21	3.23
Shane James	??	0	5	0	0	0	82	99	405	1.18	3.17
Alex Guillen	1st year	0	4	0	0	1	221	162	4	1.29	3.98
Amir Ryan	2nd year	0	2	0	0	2	74	53	128	1.1	3.26
Carl Harvey	3rd year	0	6	0	1	0	183	101	5	1.21	3.2
Marcell Amarista	1st year	0	6	0	0	0	179	92	3	1.19	3.11
Wily Liriano	???	1	3	0	0	0	212	145	5	1.27	3.84

Okay, not the best formatting, but let's choose from the above and vote upon hearing from our HOF Chair. I'll defer to our HOF Chair to lay out the rules (number of players to vote on/ alternate choice selection) below.

My 5 suggestions are Pitchers: Wily Liriano SP and looking for more RP representation Shane James.
Position players: CF Pete Pryor, Gabriel McKain LF, and Reynaldo Soriano 3B.

I think were are at a point were we do not need to nominate 5. I see Reynaldo Soriano 3B, Gabriel McKain LF as guys I would vote for. I know others dont agree on McKain and that is fine. I also feel we need to look at SS different. We need to lower the offensive statistics needed to get in. I dont think Oswaldo Martinez should get in, but might deserve consideration. Another up for consideration might be Aroldis Torres. I dont see any pitchers that jump out at me.

I suggest that each of us nominate up to 5 names we have as suggestions and vote on them with 5 pts for 1st pick, 4 pts for 2nd pick, 3 pts for 3rd pick 2 pts for 4th pick and 1 pt for 5th pick. The top 2 players with the most points move to the locked category to suggest to the rest of the owners. Third and 4th place would be suggestions.

Soriano
McKain
Amarista
Tanner?

Honestly Soriano and Pryor are the only two i can convince myself of.

If i need 4 i would add Amarista and D.Harvey

Sounds like Soriano is a lock for everyone. I relooked at Pryor and can get behind him as well, great defense. My picks to this point:

Soriano
McKain
Pryor